2 ms·
It would be a disaster if an immigrant helped bring his entire family out of poverty. We better do something to prevent that. That said, how does it benefit th
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
It would be a disaster if an immigrant helped bring his entire family out of poverty. We better do something to prevent that.
That said, how does it benefit the US if the immigrant keeps his money here?
Skilled workers in India should be able to get above-average pay.
They do. It still puts them well below the US poverty line.
Taking that graph at face value, the Indian immigrants could have no jobs at all, and still live better in the US than in India.
Very true. Most poor Americans, who typically have no job at all, still have a higher standard of living than an upper middle class developer in India. So what?
"What's the difference in value between an Indian worker compared to a native one?"
Wages for developers will be lowered. This will cause quantity demanded to increase, resulting in more software being created. This will increase productivity and benefit consumers. I don't see any reason to believe that all the software we could possibly need is currently being created - do you?
- sp332 15y agoMoving someone else out of poverty would be nice, but would you give up your job to do it? More specifically, do you think that family is entitled to your income? I don't see why the USA should pick skilled workers to move here just to compete with the workers we have, who are already struggling to find jobs in this messed-up economy. It still puts them well below the US poverty line. The US poverty line is completely irrelevant to a worker in India. Anyway, it's artificially adjusted to keep 20% of the US population below the line, so it's not useful as an indication of actual poverty. Most poor Americans, who typically have no job at all, still have a higher standard of living than an upper middle class developer in India. So what? I answered that in the very next sentence. If it's a simple matter of bringing Indians out of poverty, there's no reason for them to compete with skilled workers here. We could continue to bring random people here from India, which is the opposite of what the article recommends. In fact we should focus on the poorest and least-skilled workers. I didn't see anything in this discussion about programmers.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoMore specifically, do you think that family is entitled to your income? No. Nor am I entitled to a particular job. I'm only advocating allowing the job to go to the person who will offer the best cost/benefit ratio. I'm not advocating we should make it illegal to give the job to one person or another, you are. Anyway, it's artificially adjusted to keep 20% of the US population below the line, so it's not useful as an indication of actual poverty. This is very true, but regardless - the bottom 95'th percentile of India is poorer than the bottom 5'th percentile of the US. I didn't see anything in this discussion about programmers. My arguments are not specific to programmers. I would also advocate bringing over Indian cooks and house cleaners, subject to various non-protectionist limitations. (In short, I want to limit immigration to people who leave their cultural baggage at home and who won't vote away our freedom. I've discussed this in the past: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=619122 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=619122 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=477733 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=477733 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1144340 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1144340 )