3 ms·
It's not like there aren't high-skilled jobs in other countries, where those immigrants whom we educate could get jobs. So it's your desire to consign the Indi
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
It's not like there aren't high-skilled jobs in other countries, where those immigrants whom we educate could get jobs.
So it's your desire to consign the Indian would-be immigrant to a life of poverty (i.e., poorer than the bottom 5% of the US [1]) just to make sure your wage stays above $150k/year?
But as long as you are happy with me shipping jobs to India, I guess it's all good.
[1] http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-the-have-nots/ http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-t...
- ThaddeusQuay2 15y agoIf the argument is that their presence here makes our country richer, then the more smart Indians that there are in India, the richer that country will become.
- jbooth 15y agoThat's really the crux of it. We can pay the smartest people in the world to work here, or we can pay them to work elsewhere. If they work here, we get the externalities. Hence, no-brainer.
- jellicle 15y agoThe externalities of adding more workers to an economy at less than full capacity are negative. The public gets to support the $80K native who just got laid off, and the extra corporate profits are shipped off to an overseas subsidiary and the CEO's annual bonus, never to be seen again.
- jbooth 15y agoThe economy isn't just a single lump. There's a severe shortage of competent technical talent that we're all familiar with. If someone expects to make 80k and they haven't updated their skills since the 90s, yeah they're gonna get laid off to make room for someone who can hack it. There's still a need for that someone. Artificial scarcity isn't a good thing for the industry.
- rdtsc 15y agoOh so you are turning this into a charity case. The primary goal shifted to "help the Indian worker" not to "help the American economy". Ok, let's roll with that. If that is the case here is a proposal: pay each skilled worker turned away and replaced by an American worker a stipend to help them rise above poverty in their country (say $2k/year?) then go and hire an American worker and pay them base salary-stipend.
- macspoofing 15y ago>So it's your desire to consign the Indian would-be immigrant to a life of poverty just to make sure your wage stays above $150k/year The reality is that the government will make policies that favour citizens over foreigners. So yes, it may be someone's desire to cosign an Indian would-be immigrant to a life of poverty just to keep their wage stable. We're already doing that by not taking in unlimited immigrants from, say, war-torn Africa. >But as long as you are happy with me shipping jobs to India, I guess it's all good. Skilled immigration has nothing to do with offshoring.
- sp332 15y agoWe already have tons of refugees in the USA. In New Hampshire for example (a very libertarian state, with not much sympathy for socialist programs), we have a large contingent of Somali refugees. They are not skilled workers. I'm not saying everything has gone smoothly, but they have been made welcome by their new neighbors. I think charity (giving something to people who don't seem to deserve it) is much more palatable here than entitlement (giving something to people who think they do deserve it).
- yummyfajitas 15y agoSkilled immigration has nothing to do with offshoring. Sure it does. Both are methods of tapping into the labor pool overseas. We're already doing that by not taking in unlimited immigrants from, say, war-torn Africa. Very true. Our unwillingness to take on more refugees has resulted in thousands of people being tortured, raped and murdered. Are you advocating this policy?
- prodigal_erik 15y agoMost African cultures have not completed the demographic transition. Until that happens somehow, those cultures will exceed the carrying capacity of any environment, and war over inadequate resources. With unlimited immigration, the billion in Africa would continue moving until America became equally inhospitable. If anything, our population is already too high, verging on disposable "life is cheap" levels. We haven't learned to make a civilization that values individuals and treats them decently, except when they are scarce enough that resources are going underused (making it clear to everyone that we benefit from their presence).
- sp332 15y ago1. Why give $150,000/year to an immigrant who will send some of that money back to his/her home country? The "no-brainer" is to keep the money here. 2. Skilled workers in India should be able to get above-average pay. (If the situation is really that bad, the ones who are willing to travel elsewhere to get education and jobs should do much better than average.) Taking that graph at face value, the Indian immigrants could have no jobs at all, and still live better in the US than in India. They wouldn't have to compete with skilled workers here at all. You're looking at more skilled workers and thinking that they will add to our economy. So you're asking, "What's the absolute value of (say) and Indian worker to our economy?" But I'm thinking it's closer to a zero-sum game - more immigrants will mean less work for native workers - and I'm asking, "What's the difference in value between an Indian worker compared to a native one?"
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt would be a disaster if an immigrant helped bring his entire family out of poverty. We better do something to prevent that. That said, how does it benefit the US if the immigrant keeps his money here? Skilled workers in India should be able to get above-average pay. They do. It still puts them well below the US poverty line. Taking that graph at face value, the Indian immigrants could have no jobs at all, and still live better in the US than in India. Very true. Most poor Americans, who typically have no job at all, still have a higher standard of living than an upper middle class developer in India. So what? "What's the difference in value between an Indian worker compared to a native one?" Wages for developers will be lowered. This will cause quantity demanded to increase, resulting in more software being created. This will increase productivity and benefit consumers. I don't see any reason to believe that all the software we could possibly need is currently being created - do you?
- sp332 15y agoMoving someone else out of poverty would be nice, but would you give up your job to do it? More specifically, do you think that family is entitled to your income? I don't see why the USA should pick skilled workers to move here just to compete with the workers we have, who are already struggling to find jobs in this messed-up economy. It still puts them well below the US poverty line. The US poverty line is completely irrelevant to a worker in India. Anyway, it's artificially adjusted to keep 20% of the US population below the line, so it's not useful as an indication of actual poverty. Most poor Americans, who typically have no job at all, still have a higher standard of living than an upper middle class developer in India. So what? I answered that in the very next sentence. If it's a simple matter of bringing Indians out of poverty, there's no reason for them to compete with skilled workers here. We could continue to bring random people here from India, which is the opposite of what the article recommends. In fact we should focus on the poorest and least-skilled workers. I didn't see anything in this discussion about programmers.