3 ms·
> Is Apple being Pro-CCP with this change? I don't think Apple is Pro-CCP, Apple is Pro-Being-Able-To-Do-Business-In-China, which means doing whatever the CCP
by kelnos 4y ago
> Is Apple being Pro-CCP with this change?
I don't think Apple is Pro-CCP, Apple is Pro-Being-Able-To-Do-Business-In-China, which means doing whatever the CCP tells you to do, even if it means compromising your ethics.
- dkokelley 4y agoAt the risk of being an Apple apologist, their manufacturing is effectively held hostage by China. Yes Apple is taking the "make more profit" choice, but the alternative is pretty devastating to the company. Long term, Apple needs to diversify their manufacturing footprint. (Note that I still think Apple would adhere to the CCP's requests/laws just to be able to sell in China. China would ban Apple products if they believed Apple was not cooperative.)
- bb88 4y agoAll tech companies that rely upon China for manufacturing are in this situation -- not just Apple.
- dkokelley 4y agoAgreed to a point. Smaller companies can more easily get enough manufacturing capacity elsewhere, but larger companies are trapped by finding that capacity, technical ability, and hitting the price points they need at scale.
- fmajid 4y agoThey’re already diversifying their manufacturing to Vietnam, India and Malaysia because random draconian zero-Covid lockdowns have been very disruptive to their supply chain, not out of any high principle. The protesters should use these little gizmos instead: https://www.sandisk.com/goto/connect https://www.sandisk.com/goto/connect Basically micro web servers with MicroSD cards for storage, a battery and WiFi AP with 2h battery life and in the form factor of a chunky flash drive. You can power them off a power bank for more airtime.
- hellfish 4y ago
- sneak 4y agoApple's "home constituency" if anything is China; approximately 100% of all Apple devices are made in China by Chinese nationals. Apple is more a Chinese company than an American one, in practice. The CCP ultimately controls Apple as thoroughly as any US federal government lawmaking body or regulator. I wouldn't be surprised if the CCP starts demanding that Apple start making changes to their worldwide software and not just the stuff released in China... They really have Apple by the balls.
- misterprime 4y agoWhich company design these Chinese-made Apple products? Where is that design company located? If that design company stopped outputting anything, what would the Chinese-made Apple product making company do? I'm guessing they would keep making more of the same and end up with a stale product in a few years.
- pessimizer 4y agoApple doesn't love China in particular. It would gladly cripple protestor communications in the US if threatened, too.
- user3939382 4y ago> compromising your ethics My more cynical view is that there are no ethics to compromise. The ethic is make money. Any appearance of ethics is there as a marketing gimmick.
- runeks 4y agoApple is a publicly traded company. It's beholden to the ethics of its shareholders.
- flumpcakes 4y ago> compromising your ethics Is disabling a feature for all citizens within a geographical region "compromising your ethics" I would argue not. Different countries have different laws, including what kind of radio spectrum a phone is able to use. These have to be respected. As distasteful as it is, "respecting" the laws of an autocratic country. Now if Apple was handing over geolocation information for apple users on bulk to the CCP, or compiling lists of "likely" dissidents or <insert-minority-group> then I think we are at least knee-deep in unethical waters. But they'll probably be some people out there who say Apple-the-company is completely ethical unless they themselves are the ones pulling the trigger. I kind of disagree on this outlook, but legally again they might be right. (If you take your ethical/moral bases on that of current law.)