6 ms·
The No-Brainer Issue of the Year: Let High-Skill Immigrants Stay
- anamax 15y agoIf the advocates of high-skill immigration are so smart, why do they keep tying high-skill immigration to massive low-skill immigration and amnesty, two issues which are big losers?
- jbooth 15y agoYou're the only one bringing up Mexicans. So I'm not sure who you're complaining about. They're associated, rather than "linked" because, well, they're both immigration driven by a labor shortage.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoAnamax didn't bring up Mexicans, and it's not his hangup. Here is video of Obama talking about how great a startup visa is, and then tying the startup visa to comprehensive immigration reform. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/innovations/post/obamas-immigration-dodge/2011/07/07/gIQAyYXV2H_blog.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/innovations/post/obamas-...
- jbooth 15y agoI didn't play the video but I seriously doubt that Obama used the word "amnesty". "Low-skill immigration and amnesty" is quite clearly talking about latino immigrants. Not accusing him of being racist or anything but that's who he's talking about. Comprehensive immigration reform is needed in some form and a startup visa is one aspect of immigration reform. So it's really not outlandish to include it when talking about the subject. I'll spare you a websters-mirriam definition of comprehensive, immigration and reform. Sorry, the original comment just sounded like off-topic whining to me. Lots of putting words in people's mouths, very little contribution. EDIT: And the conservative downvote brigade has arrived. I'll just call it a day here.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoSo it's really not outlandish to include it when talking about the subject. If you want the startup visa to pass, there is a very good reason to do it by itself: the startup visa is likely to pass, whereas comprehensive immigration reform is not. Lots of putting words in people's mouths, very little contribution. It contributes even less to deny his claims, which are basically correct. Obama's blueprint for immigration reform does include amnesty (you need to scroll to page 3 to find it). http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/rss_viewer/immigration_blueprint.pdf http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/rss_viewer/imm...
- jbooth 15y agoThe "path to citizenship" outlined there has very little in common with what comes to mind when you say "amnesty". Read the language there, it's all about burdens on illegal immigrants and prerequisites, after which they can get in the back of the line to apply for citizenship. "Amnesty" implies something more similar to what Reagan did. Again, nobody was talking about this at all until anamax brought it up. And Obama proposing a startup visa by itself absolutely will not pass. You know why? Because it would involve Obama proposing it. See the House Republicans refusing to pass a tax cut this week.
- anamax 15y ago> Read the language there, it's all about burdens on illegal immigrants and prerequisites, after which they can get in the back of the line to apply for citizenship. "back of the line"? They're starting in front of everyone who applied to immigrate, didn't get accepted, and waited until they did. Are you really arguing that it isn't amnesty because there are some conditions?
- jbooth 15y agoAnything that takes over a decade to successfully execute isn't quite "amnesty" by my definition. "Amnesty" is like "Hey, you're good to go!". Amnesty International isn't campaigning for prisoners to be released "about 10 years from now".
- anamax 15y ago> They're associated, rather than "linked" because, well, they're both immigration driven by a labor shortage. Most people understand that I'm talking about the political process, said process being how the US makes changes in immigration law. The advocates of "high skill immigration" are asking for different changes to said law than the advocates for low skill plus "forgiveness". However, they're putting both sets of changes into a single package. As to the "labor shortage", I've done farm labor and other "jobs that americans won't do". The "shortage" is a combination of wage-busting and unwillingness to pay for the relevant automation. Then again, you won't find me arguing that someone is entitled to cheap golf, to mention one of the arguments for low skill immigration.
- tomjen3 15y agoYeah that is a no-brainer: you have to have no brain to be against it and at the same time anybody with a brain knows it is never going to pass. Why do you guys keep posting these articles?
- sp332 15y agoThat doesn't seem like a no-brainer. Wouldn't it be harder for skilled Americans to find jobs here if they're competing with immigrants? It's not like there aren't high-skilled jobs in other countries, where those immigrants whom we educate could get jobs. The subtitle says Our policy toward the world's best and brightest is currently: "Welcome! Enjoy this expensive education. Now go home!" Does that make any sense? But I think it makes even less sense to say to native-born Americans, "Enjoy this expensive education. Now go to Europe to get a job, because we decided to hire an Indian instead".
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt's not like there aren't high-skilled jobs in other countries, where those immigrants whom we educate could get jobs. So it's your desire to consign the Indian would-be immigrant to a life of poverty (i.e., poorer than the bottom 5% of the US [1]) just to make sure your wage stays above $150k/year? But as long as you are happy with me shipping jobs to India, I guess it's all good. [1] http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-the-have-nots/ http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-t...
- ThaddeusQuay2 15y agoIf the argument is that their presence here makes our country richer, then the more smart Indians that there are in India, the richer that country will become.
- jbooth 15y agoThat's really the crux of it. We can pay the smartest people in the world to work here, or we can pay them to work elsewhere. If they work here, we get the externalities. Hence, no-brainer.
- jellicle 15y agoThe externalities of adding more workers to an economy at less than full capacity are negative. The public gets to support the $80K native who just got laid off, and the extra corporate profits are shipped off to an overseas subsidiary and the CEO's annual bonus, never to be seen again.
- devs1010 15y agoNo system is going to be perfect, how can "high-skill" immigrants be evaluated with absolute certainty that they are, in-fact, highly skilled. I am sick and tired of employers in the U.S. viewing people with degrees from universities in third-world countries as if they are equal to a degree from the U.S (and thus possibly passing over US workers who may not have completed a degree program). I realize that some immigrants come here for college and that would validate their skills-sets, such as "if they graduate from the U.S. university with high grades, then they can stay and work" but it seems to me a lot of these supposedly highly skilled, supposedly "better than the average American" tech workers are people who were educated exclusively in another country and its not comparing apples to apples, in my opinion.
- macspoofing 15y ago>No system is going to be perfect, how can "high-skill" immigrants be evaluated with absolute certainty that they are Why do you need "absolute certainty"
- devs1010 15y agoBecause I would at least prefer to err on the side of not hurting American-born workers, rather than err on the side of letting in incompetent "tech talent"
- anghyflawn 15y agoI find it very hard to believe that many American employers hire foreigners, with all the paperwork that entails, unless they are persuaded that the foreigner in question is indeed better than the Americans in their pool (modulo wages, but there's a wage floor for H1B, and in any case it's a question of value).
- devs1010 15y agoThis is completely untrue, I get the feeling you haven't worked a place that has many H1B employees. All I can say is it has been quite obvious that some H1B employees were not quite as sharp as their American counterparts at some places I have worked (not saying all H1B workers, but some). Sure, some are good, but they are not all hired because they have a better skillset and are better overall than their American counterparts, this is rather ridiculous.
- ThaddeusQuay2 15y ago1) Importing skilled immigrants is like exporting jobs because most of these people go back to their own countries, and those who stay take the place of a US citizen who could have had the job, if our education system was better and our government's policies were otherwise aligned with the welfare of its people. 2) All routine immigration should be immediately stopped, and indefinitely kept that way. Exceptions should be made only for the few, true geniuses who could definitely benefit the US in a big way. http://youtube.com/watch?v=9PpaoZE8oXk http://youtube.com/watch?v=9PpaoZE8oXk NumbersUSA - Immigration by the Numbers - Part 2 of 2 http://youtube.com/watch?v=XyTmClBU7nA http://youtube.com/watch?v=XyTmClBU7nA NumbersUSA - Immigration by the Numbers - Part 1 of 2 http://NumbersUSA.com http://NumbersUSA.com
- zeteo 15y ago> immigrants [...] who stay take the place of a US citizen who could have had the job, if our education system was better and our government's policies were otherwise aligned with the welfare of its people. All routine immigration should be immediately stopped, and indefinitely kept that way Yes, and to be consistent also ban imports. Each suitcase produced abroad takes the place of one that could have been produced in the US, if the manufacturing industry was better and governmental policies were aligned with the interests of blue collar workers. I mean, North Korea is so successful, there's no reason to not emulate their economic policies!
- rubashov 15y agoThe "utilitarian" case for halting immigration is obvious to me. But utilitarian arguments are what the pro-immigration people use, too. I find it interesting that nobody ever talks about national solidarity anymore when discussing immigration. It seems taken for granted that the USA is not a real nation, a real "people". It's just some sort of bazaar for various people with nothing in common to do business, so let in the hordes to do business. No need to worry about literally millions of people coming here without strong loyalties and intent to fully and permanently assimilate.
- opinali 15y agoYour major mistake (and there are many...) is believing that only "true geniuses" bring great benefit to the country. For every Sergey Brin who can create Google, there is a thousand of engineers who can "only" implement Google; if the latter are too rare or too expensive, the great innovators or entrepreneurs (either immigrant or native) may not have much success... also, very rarely a "true genius" possesses that status before immigrating. Albert Einstein was already a Nobel Prize winner before coming to the US, both that's the exception not the rule. (And he only settled in the US due to Hitler and the war... most people of a certain age, already successful and wealthy, don't bother with the pain of immigration.) Sergey's family would only qualify as "regular" H1B-class immigrants (a Math teacher and a climate scientist). Finally, it's very funny how people like you are favorable to a closed working market (let's say this is possible) but an open, fair and competitive market for everything else. Will you be happy if all foreign countries fight back with unfair commercial practices? This is not a theoretical question, as you already have at least one important commercial partner that's strong and ingenious enough to screw you -- China -- and this is apparently bad enough already. The fact is, the globalization cat is out of the bag and there's no way back, and no way to play only half of the music.
- rdtsc 15y agoIt's a cost issue usually disguised as a "skilled immigrant" issue. Large companies want technical workers (the new miners and factory workers) who are willing to accept a much lower wage than native workers. So when they talk about "skilled" they usually mean "skilled and willing to work for $40k/year instead of $80k/year". Just look at how many H1B positions are advertised and how much legal but shady stuff goes on. Put ad in local paper among classifieds for "free dirt available", if any resumes are received from US citizens they are discarded (note they have to be "considered" but not accepted), and so on. If it was just about "skills" there would be no need for this shit to go on. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCbFEgFajGU&feature=plcp&context=C301d875UDOEgsToPDskKn5dk5-5tIALOarSLcJ1JL http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCbFEgFajGU&feature=plcp&...
- scarface548 15y agoyou cannot hire a h1b for 40k/year, minimum prevailing wage requirement prevents you from doing so.
- untog 15y agoYou can hire an H1B for 45k/year. I know because I was that H1B at one point. My previous employer gave me quick pay rises once I proved that I was capable, but not everyone is so lucky.
- scarface548 15y agoWas the prevailing wage where/when you were employed less than 45k?. If it was then you were not undercutting the american worker,if not your employer was doing something illegal. From personal experience hiring a H1B is anything but cheap, lawyer fees and all.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- untog 15y agoThe prevailing wage was $45k. This was for a programming role in New York City- I do not know anyone that gets paid $45k. I'm unsure how they calculate prevailing wages, but I'd suggest that the formula could do with some tweaking.
- geebee 15y agoThis issue comes up a lot on hacker news. While I do stongly support a stronger emphasis on skilles immigrants, and I do believe STEM grads are valuable, I believe this article (and this genre of article in general) overlook a critical point. I've mentioned a RAND study many times in my comments on hn. This study took a very objective look at the pay, career prospects, completion time, attrition rate, and so forth of STEM grad degrees vs the professions (MD, JD, DDS, MBA, etc). The conclusion reached was that STEM grad degrees are unappealing to young americans because they are no longer competitive with other career paths available to the "best and brightest". So, does it make sense to specifically staple green cards to evey stem diploma when the most objective research suggests the shortage may be market driven? I don't have a definitive answer. I think it's a complex question wothy of discussion, and not at all the no-brainer the atlantic article claims it it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- opinali 15y agoMaybe the government / society / businesses / schools can solve the problem in some way; but any solution would take many years to develop - it's not like millions of extra STEM grads will be popping out of college a week after you start some kind of campaign to make it more appealing. (Which doesn't mean you should not start it right now, in parallel with adequate immigration policies.) Also, this problem is not unique to America. The shortage of skilled STEM professionals is universal in every country with a modern economy. And I don't think this will ever change; STEM is not appealing to everybody, it's just too hard and too boring for most people. I don't say that in a demeaning way; Law or Health Sciences for example, are too hard and too boring for my thick skull. People are different. But in the modern world, the increasing demand for people with a STEM-friendly brain is clearly exceeding the percentage of the population who both have that kind of brain and are lucky/wealthy/hard-working enough to afford full education.
- zeteo 15y agoBut of course the completion times and attrition rates are high. Anyone who's worked in the science academia is well aware of the fact that way too many American K-12 graduates, no matter how much they may like a STEM career, are woefully unprepared to deal with the math involved in it. The attrition rates and general unpleasantness of these majors result directly from this factor. Until K-12 math gets fixed for good, you need either some stopgap measures to fill those jobs or the inanity to graduate engineers who can't do basic math (and then drive over the bridges they design).