6 ms·
Boil Water Notice for City of Houston
- giardini 4y agohttps://www.click2houston.com/news/local/2022/11/28/boil-water-notice-issued-for-the-entire-city-of-houston-after-water-pressure-dropped-due-to-power-outage-officials-announce/ https://www.click2houston.com/news/local/2022/11/28/boil-wat...
- wahnfrieden 4y ago
- tdeck 4y agoIt sounds like they had a brief service disruption and the underlying issue is already fixed. They just need to give the system time to flush out any questionable water. It's by no means ideal and seems like they should have had better backups (gravity, generator power) but doesn't seem to be a massive indictment of the system.
- encryptluks2 4y agoHopefully, but let's not forget about the power crisis that Texas had semi recently which may continue to give Texas a bad name in regards to infrastructure for a long time to come. I doubt that the residents affected forget that quickly.
- jkepler 4y agoThat because media coverage is generally anti-bitcoin mining. What many don't understand is that bitcoin mining at industrial scale incentivizes energy production, because the miners seek out cheap, otherwise underutilized energy (otherwise they aren't profitable). During last July's heatwave, Texas's industrial bitcoin mining base "allow[ed] for over 1% of total grid capacity to be pushed back onto the grid for retail and commercial use.” [1] No other industrial-scale use of electricity can be turned off and back on when the grid needs excess capacity without harming that industrial production---you can't shut off a steel mill without enormous damage to production, or turn off a hospital without loss of life; but energy grid operators can sign contacts with bitcoin miners to have the right to dial them down to meet peak grid demand. And yet, the NY Post article I sighted here spins the story anti-miners, missing the point: had the miner not been consuming power, the grid would have had 1% less to meet the peak heatwave demand. “There are over 1,000 megawatts worth of Bitcoin mining load that responded to ERCOTs conservation request by turning off their machines to conserve energy for the grid.” Imagine if there were ten times as many miners there---they would have been able to provide 10% additional power to the grid during peak demand. [1] https://nypost.com/2022/07/13/texas-bitcoin-miners-halt-operations-to-save-energy-amid-heat-wave/ https://nypost.com/2022/07/13/texas-bitcoin-miners-halt-oper...).
- james4k 4y agoYou really drank that koolaid.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- jkepler 4y agoConnect the public water utility to a bitcoin mining operation, with contractual rights to dial down/turn off the bitcoin mining and use that electricity as backup should the water treatment plant's other source of electricity fails. When they don't need the backup power it provides security to the bitcoin network, and when they do need it, its there.
- eska 4y agoIf the same happened in a city in another country you just wouldn’t hear about it on international news.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- glaucon 4y agoI'm failing to find any reference to this incident on any non US website. BBC, Deutsche Welle and the Guardian... All no.
- shapefrog 4y ago[flagged]
- Throw10987 4y agoCase in point, Sydney Au is starting water restrictions despite record rainfall due to quality of water in catchments.. Not that far from boiling water. https://www.nsw.gov.au/environment-land-and-water/water-restrictions https://www.nsw.gov.au/environment-land-and-water/water-rest...
- paranoidrobot 4y ago> starting water restrictions Not starting. "The NSW Government has announced that Water Wise Guidelines have replaced Level 1 water restrictions [...] The restrictions have eased, but let’s stay water wise."
- EdwardDiego 4y agoYeah, nah, it is rather far from boil water notices tbh. Rather heavier rainfalls into mountainous bushclad terrain can significantly increase turbidity and faecal coeliforms in a reservoir. So treating each cumec takes longer - filters clog faster, UV needs to be applied for longer... Hence the water restrictions - throughput has to decrease to maintain quality. Boil water notices occur when your water treatment has entirely failed.
- alkonaut 4y agoThis isn't a sign of that, this is a sign that it's working as intended. The Michigan lead pipes or whatever might be a better story to point to if you want to show a failure like the one you suggest.
- dalbasal 4y agoWhen you already believe something, you can start seeing proofs everywhere. Water grids malfunction. Some water management departments suck. Some are good. Some cities have better infrastructure than others. Inevitably though, these are taken as "see! I'm right." Tories are evil. Democrats are useless. Communism doesn't work. Capitalism hates humans. Bureaucrats suck. Privatisation is a failure. Regulators are ne'erdowells. Etc. Etc. One of the first principles of formal logic deals with this sort of thing. Reductio and absurdum. When a statement or logical method can yield every conclusion and it's opposite, it's the logic or assumptions that are false.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoI don't actually believe it from this example alone but wanted to say it. Your reading is a little simplistic and condescending
- dalbasal 4y agoFair enough. I can see why you say this, and I would probably feel the same way if our positions were reversed. Perhaps there is a better way that I should have phrased this. OTOH, I'm somewhat stumped. Some forms tend to be condescending or dismissive. Assigning motives, for example. Meta, like my response to your comment. Yet, motivated reasoning exists. Cognitive fallacies recur. Etc. I don't want to be condescending or bad faith. But in these cases, I don't see much daylight between condescending and just not commenting. There is such a thing as adopting a worldview, and then suddenly seeing everything through that lens. As you say, you already hold the position that "the American project is failing its residents." When the water grid has a fault, it's proof of this. My contention is that if you had previously adopted an alternative worldview, you'd hold the recurring culprit (capitalism, bureaucracy, republicans, environmentalism, etc.) responsible by the same logic.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoI get what you're saying but you should recognize a level of "meta" in peoples behavior as well rather than take for granted a kind of intellectual immediacy to what people say. I'm aware of the audience here and have intention to agitate. To be open with you. Also your line of thought can apply to really anything, not just the problem of crediting
- refurb 4y agoI mean Canada had a bunch of people die from unsafe drinking water not that long ago. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walkerton_E._coli_outbreak https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walkerton_E._coli_outbreak
- Narretz 4y agoThe article is very in-depth and shows a long list of failures, well into the disaster response. But it was also 22 years ago.
- refurb 4y agoHere are all the current water quality notices in Canada right now. There are dozens of them. http://www.watertoday.ca/textm.asp http://www.watertoday.ca/textm.asp
- Narretz 4y agoThis only suggests that quality control and warning system are working. The 2000 case is infamous because both didn't work and caused deaths and permanent injury.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoDepends. This sounds like an incident. If this is a regular occurrence then there's something that needs to be fixed, that is, funds need to be reallocated to redevelop core infrastructure.
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoIt is not just America. The whole west is failing in differing ways, to differing degrees, and at different states; but the heading is generally the same. This is also just the start of a lagging problem. It’s civilizational cancer or HIV, not a laceration or broken bone. The whole immune system is unable to detect what is killing the body, let alone act against the threat to its existence. By the time it is obvious to the naive and short sighted that there is a problem, things will long have been terminal.
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoOr the Texas project anyway.
- cuteboy19 4y agoSo why is water unsafe below a certain pressure?
- phnofive 4y agoWater grids are designed to flow in only one direction; a drop in pressure allows potentially contaminated water to flow backward into the pipes, e.g., from a crack that allows a small amount of water out into the surrounding soil.
- cuteboy19 4y agoI feel like no matter the pressure, if there is a crack and a dirty puddle outside then it will always contaminate the water
- dale_glass 4y agoNo, if pressure is higher on the inside it'll just constantly go from inside the pipe to outside it, and outside contaminants won't leak in.
- c_o_n_v_e_x 4y agoSimilar concept... clean rooms are positively pressured to keep germs, dirt, etc. from entering the room. Isolation rooms are negatively pressured to keep bad stuff from leaving.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoooooo.... in new delhi, india back 7-9 years ago i was living in a pretty garbage area by my normal standards and one of the things we had to be careful about was when to use the water pump. do it during off time and the water from the tap would be green, it would stink and taste like vomit. that was a really really terrible experience and bad living standards. unless you are poor and cannot afford any other reasonably okay living place, one should not be living in those conditions.
- 4y ago
- dalbasal 4y agoSo... some ignorant questions? (1) Is there much daylight between unsafe to drink and unsafe to shower/etc. IE, is there such a thing as nonpotable water that's still OK for domestic use? (2) If there is such a thing, are there major cost or environmental savings to be had from running a nonpotable water grid? My thinking is that treating water at home is not that hard. You can easily have one filtered tap at home. It's cheap and easy to retrofit. Is it not overkill/inefficient to run a drinking water grid when 99% of the water waters lawns and washes dishes?
- rsynnott 4y ago> My thinking is that treating water at home is not that hard. You can easily have one filtered tap at home. It's cheap and easy to retrofit. I mean, define 'filtered'. A brita-type filter will do precisely nothing for most things that require a boil notice (nor will it do anything for most heavy metal contaminants etc). In general, "filtered" taps primarily remove chlorine and calcium carbonate, mostly for taste reasons. Doing actual water treatment at home is not going to be particularly economic or safe.
- World177 4y agoWater treatment at home isn’t difficult as long as it isn’t polluted with something bad like hydrocarbons. A distiller can be purchased for less than $100. There are many homes in Texas that are using heaters that aren’t heat pumps, so in the winter, it probably is economical if excluding the original purchase price. A reverse osmosis system can also be purchased for less than $500, but requires more maintenance.
- lm28469 4y ago> A brita-type filter will do precisely nothing for most things that require a boil notice Well, it might do something, give a nice warm and humid substrate for bacterias to develop
- olliej 4y agoWhat about the reverse osmosis filters many homes have?
- dickersnoodle 4y ago
- SaintGhurka 4y agoWas it the grid? The linked article only says "power outage", but doesn't mention a grid failure. Do you have another source with details?
- Guthur 4y agoExactly as planned I think. Welcome your new feudal lords, they may throw you a bottle of water (probably Coke though), but watch you don't choke on the plastic.
- notinfuriated 4y agoWow, real insightful snarky comment. I got tired of this nonsense when Texans were doing it to Californians over wildfires and their own power failures. And I got even more tired of it when Californians did it to Texans.
- olliej 4y agoI wonder how long this will last? a boiled water requirement in response to a short term pressure loss seems more like a "lets be safe" rule than a "things are contaminated". When I was a kid we had a 3 week boiled water restriction due to a seagull getting trapped and dying inside a water tank.
- devilbunny 4y agoBare minimum of three days after pressure is restored for microbial cultures to be considered negative.
- nunez 4y agofyi: houston is a BIG metropolitan area, over 10k sq miles. this only affects parts of the city core.