4 ms·
How many people use ACLs?
by wmf 4y ago
How many people use ACLs?
- pinewurst 4y agoIn the real world only a small minority even use NFSv4 and that mostly for the figleaf of encryption via (yuck!) Kerberos. As a (too) long time storage industry person, I have hard numbers on this.
- chungy 4y agoIt's primarily a corporate-level thing, but just as Windows has a strong set of ACLs that people at home ignore, it could be the same scenario on Linux.
- asveikau 4y agoThis is a Yogi Berra type comment. "ACLs aren't supported. Nobody uses them."
- wmf 4y agoNot really. Linux supports "old" posix ACLs and chungy is complaining that it doesn't support "new" rich ACLs. My point is why bother upgrading a feature that no one uses.
- chungy 4y agoI think "no one" is a fairly tall claim: They are well-used on all the operating systems that do support them. Mind also, "old POSIX ACLs" came from a POSIX draft: they never made it into POSIX. While being an extremely simple expansion of the Unix modes, they are only ever additive and do not support fine-grained permissions that NFSv4 allows for. They're sometimes better than the standard mode bits, but they very often come up short of being useful in the real world.
- nerdponx 4y agoI have used them to set up a group-readable/writable directory to ensure that all subdirectories remain so.
- cesarb 4y ago> How many people use ACLs? Everyone who uses systemd. Try it yourself: do a getfacl on the files inside /var/log/journal on a system with persistent logging enabled (if it's disabled, these files will be at /run/log/journal instead).