4 ms·
Imagine if we decided the letter Z needed to be removed from our language because of Russia’s atrocities. But I think there’s plenty of room for understanding
by Waterluvian 4y ago
Imagine if we decided the letter Z needed to be removed from our language because of Russia’s atrocities.
But I think there’s plenty of room for understanding and nuance rather than just saying, “hey people who are offended by this symbol, read your history books and toughen up!” Millions were exterminated by those wearing the symbol.
There is no such thing as ownership of a symbol. It has different, equally valid meanings to different audiences.
- thomassmith65 4y agoIf the Nazis had used a common letter like Z, there would not be the same stigma attached to the symbol. That this is so obvious suggests your argument has a flaw.
- Waterluvian 4y agoHow common must a symbol be before it’s immune to the stigma of murdering millions? I’m curious how one calculates that. Also: don’t mistake an observation for an argument. I’m not implying anything. I think it is an interesting thought.
- philippejara 4y agoThis is a question without a general answer, because stigma changes on a person by person basis and there isn't a single thing that will end up immune to it, there is no better example of this taken to the extreme as some fringe groups holding the stigma of white supremacy over an "ok" symbol or a bowl cut[0]. The swastika is a bit more complicated because the western world's exposure to it isn't all that big, but I don't see how a symbol that is used by probably over 10% of the world population today and has been used for over 5000 years should be shunned, especially when you consider that it's not even the same symbol most of the time! At the end of the day most of this stigma wouldn't be an issue if people would just stop assuming malice from others by default. [0]: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ok-symbol-hand-gesture-anti-defamation-league-bowl-cut-racism-hatred/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ok-symbol-hand-gesture-anti-def...
- suramya_tomar 4y ago
- SanjayMehta 4y agoI studied in a Catholic school where there were crosses everywhere with Jesus on them. Once got into a lot of trouble for asking why an instrument of torture was considered holy. It still disturbs me to see it.
- hrnnnnnn 4y agoSomeone at my work actually suggested, with a straight face, that we do just that. I think specifically they suggested we stop referring to "gen-z" because there was a letter Z in it.
- slater- 4y ago
- squiffsquiff 4y agoYou seem to be under the misapprehensions that: - Anyone can re/claim any symbol - No other symbols have been banned You may not like or agree with it, but symbols do have owners and they do matter. Look at today's news around the USA football team and the Iranian flag today for an example.
- Waterluvian 4y agoWhat I was (poorly) trying to communicate is that no one side gets ownership to dictate how a symbol is interpreted by or affects others. By that I mean that those who see it as a religious symbol and those who see it as a symbol of nazism need to be mindful of each other. Neither “group” has moral authority to tell the other that they’re wrong about the symbol’s meaning.
- squiffsquiff 4y agoI think you're shooting at the wrong target. There's a profound and unfortunate association with the swastika in the western world. It doesn't really matter if there are 'good intentions', there are plenty of people still using it today as hate symbol
- philippejara 4y agoIt doesn't really matter if there are 'bad intentions', there are plenty of people still using it today as religious symbol. At the end of the day people are free to believe whatever they want from people using a symbol, but it will only betray their own ignorance in its history and still active use in the non-western world. The idea that a symbol still currently used by probably billions shouldn't be used because of connections only westerners make is peak eurocentrism/UScentrism.
- hulitu 4y ago> At the end of the day people are free to believe whatever they want from people using a symbol, No people are not free. Those symbols can land you in jail. > but it will only betray their own ignorance in its history and still active use in the non-western world. Yes, but this is desired. No state wants people who are able to think for themselves. People must do what they are told.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]