4 ms·
>I think culture is important. And I think it shouldn't be. Companies should be about work and professionalism, not culture and other touch feely BS. At best,
by coldtea 4y ago
>I think culture is important.
And I think it shouldn't be. Companies should be about work and professionalism, not culture and other touch feely BS.
At best, a cultural fit that would disqualify one is if they're a pacifict and the company makes weapons, or something similar.
Not if they don't like BS company mandated non-work activities, bro-style interaction, political partisanship forced upon employees, alcohol-fueld bonding, or "we overwork employees 24/7 because they are starry-eyed idiots fresh out of college with no personal life, and you should work like that too", and so on.
- deltaseventhree 4y ago>And I think it shouldn't be. Companies should be about work and professionalism, not culture and other touch feely BS. Professionalism is an artificial construct. Throughout most of human history people operated as tribes and social groups. All the touchy and feely BS was inevitable. Given that it's part of our biological and anthropological nature you literally cannot expect no team to be formed this way at all. Many teams want this level of synergy and because it is a natural part of our history and biology it is inevitable that many teams will be formed this way REGARDLESS of the law. Learn to identify these teams and join the team that fits you. I think it is completely wrong to forcefully embed yourself in a team where you don't fit in and use the law to help you remain on this team and enforce your idea of professionalism. You will literally destroy the spirit of the team. Under our current culture and law there will definitely be teams that value what you value. And that is where you fit in and that is the company you should join. But have understanding and empathy to see why this "bro-style" interaction and "alcohol fueled" bonding is necessary in other teams.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y ago<<Professionalism is an artificial construct. Most things are. Why is it a requirement to join any team at all, which also happens to be an artificial construct?
- deltaseventhree 4y agoThe concept of Teams are not a an artificial construct. They are part of biology both inside and outside of human biology. Other animals besides humans form teams as well. Professional teams are however artificial. The formalism between separating a personal life from a professional life does not exist anywhere in the animal kingdom and did not exist for most of human history. >Why is it a requirement to join any team at all, which also happens to be an artificial construct? It is not a requirement to join a team at all. You can join no team, and that is your choice. Likely though you will want to join a team to survive. In the past humans survived in groups. A human that is not part of a tribe likely had a low chance of survival. Nowadays you need to join a team to get a salary. But nowadays you have an extra option. You can join something called a "professional" team which is a team that separates your personal life from your "professional" one. However the traditional concept of a "team" still exists and you can choose not to join such a team if choose not to. I ask though that you have the wisdom to see why the concept of the "traditional team" still exists and why such teams are still effective in our society. Think about it this way. Team bonding activities still exist. They exist for a reason and that reason is because the company that created that activity WANTS you to join it. The requirement is still there. It is not unreasonable to see how some teams WANT these traditional bonding activities more then other teams. It all depends on the dynamics and for you to force the team to abide by your dynamics of "professionalism" is wrong. You have options, JOIN the team that works.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoFor the record, I don't think I completely disagree with you, but I think your argument is wrong. << The concept of Teams are not a an artificial construct. They are part of biology both inside and outside of human biology. We might be getting a little esoteric here. If "Teams" is a concept then just from that name alone you can determine that it refers to an idea ( artificial construct ). And biology does not automatically wills teams into existence ( although it might happen to result in them as our environment seems to indicate ). Do you mean evolution? << Why is it a requirement to join any team at all, >> It is not a requirement to join a team at all. >> Nowadays you need to join a team to get a salary. So it is a requirement? << Think about it this way. Team bonding activities still exist. I think that is a really bad argument. Slavery still exists ( sadly ) and I would not even dream of thinking considering recommending it. << They exist for a reason and that reason Yep, and now we evolved into something better. Could we move onto Team 2.0 so to speak? << It is not unreasonable to see how some teams WANT these traditional I guess it depends. Some traditions are more upsetting than others. Would you advocate for a team that wants to continue a tradition of child sacrifice? edit: removed specific god reference. it is not necessary for the argument to work
- coldtea 4y agoCompanies, societies, laws, customs, are "artificial constructs" too. Not letting the disabled die off in the woods is also an "artificial construct". "Make fun of gays" and "gropple the secretaries" was a team bonding ritual well favored in US companies not long ago too. "Haze the newbies" too (also in the army). What fun, eh? You're speaking from towers of huge privilege with mininal compassion. If you think what you're forcing people working for you to do - or lose their job - is bonding, think again.
- deltasevenseven 4y agoI am a transgender minority and I get paid below average for my field. Probability wise you are in a position with more privilege then me. Thus you are the one speaking from a place a minimal compassion. Think on that. Let me put more emphasis on what I thought was implied but didn't get through. I think these things need to be part of a job description. If the expectation is MADE clear to the employee before he is hired, then it's fair game. He volunteered for this stuff. I am not advocating forcing this stuff onto people who didn't know about it. The problem is etiquette. It's sort of not good to put this in the job description officially so employers need to somehow subtly convey this employees that this is what will be expected.
- coldtea 4y ago>I am a transgender minority and I get paid below average for my field. Probability wise you are in a position with more privilege then me. You might be surprised, but even if not, using the "less privileged" card from a position of someone in power enforcing illegal and unethical mandates on potential and existing employees is not the best application for it. >The problem is etiquette. It's sort of not good to put this in the job description officially so employers need to somehow subtly convey this employees that this is what will be expected. No, the problem with doing something illegal (that you can't explicitly put in the job description even) AND douchey is that it's illegal and douchey. "How you'd do this bullying coercion subtly so you get what you want and screw the employees" is not a real problem.
- 4y ago