3 ms·
>A lot of fantastical claims made in this article with little citation. Not everything comes with a citation. Things first happen, then get studied, even if al
by coldtea 4y ago
>A lot of fantastical claims made in this article with little citation.
Not everything comes with a citation. Things first happen, then get studied, even if all the signs are there.
(Also, 'little citation' my ass. The post has links to video animation AI models, studios that already do this thing, papers and relevant technologies, etc. And it's just a post, not an exhausting monography on the subject)
>I have friends who work in animation and illustration professionally. Based off their predictions, the truth is likely far more mundane.
"It's difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on not understanding it" as the saying goes.
The change will not be driven by animators, but by people hiring animators that decide to cut costs by not hiring them.
Subpar results wont be a problem, if they're still good enough. There will be people helping and people touching up the end results, but half or less of what there are now...
I.e.: " These AI models will likely just become tools that automate or simplify existing animation workflows for larger projects. This would definitely result in less labor needed for any given project."
Yes, but much more dramatically so, to the point that there will big loss of jobs in the industry.
- sdenton4 4y ago...or a bigger pie as it becomes a smaller gamble to launch an animation project...
- yunwal 4y agoI think this is probably too limited a view. My guess is that animation becomes more like photo-editing. There are still experts who do it professionally and push the boundaries of the form, but it’s also a skill that’s expected for marketing jobs, graphic designers, web devs, etc.
- coldtea 4y agoIn most cases "bigger pies" are just pipe dreams, and it's all about powerlaw distribution of profits to a few smaller players.
- yunwal 4y agoAs software has become easier and faster to write, the demand for it has only increased, and salaries have gotten higher and higher. I see no reason this couldn’t happen for animation. Studios demand more immersive, interactive experiences that require more and more detail. More animated content is generated. Every marketing team now needs 3D animators to make social media content, etc. This seems like the logical progression and doesn’t necessarily result in a loss of jobs.
- coldtea 4y ago>I see no reason this couldn’t happen for animation. Because software had room to grow into all industries - which huge ROI, applicable everywhere. Whereas animation has a capped target: it's content, of a specific type even, not a way to help other industries generate profit, like software is.
- yunwal 4y agoIn a world where everyone is basically always consuming content I don’t really see this as a hard cap. Even if you’re not mindlessly scrolling through social media or watching Netflix, you still might be watching tutorials for work, or talking on slack, where we already use gifs and emojis. It’s definitely possible that animation eats the world, it would just have to move further down the spectrum from content to regular communication.
- qualudeheart 4y agoEconomic growth has plenty of upside. I’d not be surprised to see 5-10% yoy economic growth as we approach the AGI frontier.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bradknowles 4y agoI see the animation industry as being very similar to the VFX industry, and the famous case of Rhythm & Hue winning an Oscar award for what they did on the movie "Life of Pi" in the same year they went bankrupt and out of business. The industry will still be there. But how much money you can make, and how many people you can afford to have on the payroll, that will diminish. I think Corridor Crew is showing this effect with virtually every post to their YouTube channel.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI think it would be a big mistake to discount Jevons paradox here. It's very possible that the lower cost of images and animation would greatly increase their demand, and customers would still want a person to be part of this process.
- aeturnum 4y ago> The change will not be driven by animators, but by people hiring animators that decide to cut costs by not hiring them. I have no doubt that management hopes that they will be able to cut costs through AI! My doubts come from the fact that the people most certain that this possible future will come to pass seem to be armchair experts outside the industry where people in the industry seem mostly excited about new tools and bemused with the IP issues around AI. It's not like the last 20 years have been free of disruptions from software tools? I have no more of a crystal ball than anyone else, but this is only one of many confident predictions about AI killing human experts that has not yet come to pass. It's certainly possible, but I wouldn't invest based on it.