3 ms·
I'm so curious but the article doesn't mention: how were these splines "defined"? In other words, if you have to reproduce your work for a new draft, how do you
by crazygringo 4y ago
I'm so curious but the article doesn't mention: how were these splines "defined"? In other words, if you have to reproduce your work for a new draft, how do you make sure you draw the exact same curve? (Without tracing the prior draft.)
Are there "control points" like Bézier curves have? Do those have anything to do with the placement of the whales? Or was this all just done "by eye" so that these splines assisted in drawing a perfectly smooth curve, but the result was just trial-and-error to find a curve that looks good?
- Jarmsy 4y agoAn interesting question, since you could record the positions of the whales, but that alone doesn't fully determine the curve. I guess you'd have to also record the distances along the spline between those pinned points.
- Someone 4y agoI think the pins aren’t ‘pinning’ specific points on the wood strips to specific locations, but just prevent the strip of wood from becoming a straight-lined strip of wood. The tendency of the strip of wood to straighten itself would provide enough force to make the wood slide along the pins to find the minimum energy solution. (Edit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_spline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_spline seems to confirm that)
- Jarmsy 4y agoBoth types are used - pinning and sliding. See figure 3.19 in https://www.levien.com/phd/thesis.pdf https://www.levien.com/phd/thesis.pdf
- bee_rider 4y agoIs it a requirement, to be able to copy a design without tracing? Blueprints seem to have been the main way of storing designs for quite a while. Maybe the drawings are just as good as it gets until you have computers that really want numbers. Think about buying a ship for example — I guess the person buying it would just specify a type of hull (or for high end stuff, go to a shipwright they specializes in a type of hull), and a couple dimensions. As to actually doing the design, must be their experience plus conventions built on outcomes from the field — this part of the hull has to be convex, etc etc. So, trial an error, but built up over generations.
- gregschlom 4y agoMy dad was a naval architect, so I can answer that one. Drawing was done on translucent paper (tracing paper). If you had to copy another drawing, you could just slide it under your current drawing and position a spline to match the line. Once the drawing was done, it was brought to a copy shop that used a special machine to copy it to a paper that turned blue when exposed to light (hence the term blueprint - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blueprint https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blueprint). The original drawing on tracing paper was then carefully archived, and more blueprints could be made out of it as needed.
- kakkun 4y agoI guess measure where the whales are, and hope that the flexibility of the thing you're using to re-create the line is close enough to what was used when the curve was initially created. The order's different (the curve defining the points, as opposed to points defining the curve), but it might look like what Apple provides in their CAD files for accessory makers. Take a look at p. 362 for an example: https://developer.apple.com/accessories/Accessory-Design-Guidelines.pdf https://developer.apple.com/accessories/Accessory-Design-Gui...
- Jarmsy 4y agoAn elastica curve doesn't depend on the stiffness of the material - as long as it is linearly elastic.
- sourdoughness 4y agoBoat builders do talk about “fair battens”, where batten = spline, and “fair” refers to being linearly elastic. Boat building battens can be really long, so fairness is not guaranteed. Long battens are scarfed together out of pieces cut from the same timber plank to try to maximise uniformity.