9 ms·
Why Unreal Engine 5.1 is a Deal [video]
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoYears ago I worked on an ill fated game project with the Unreal 1 engine. It is dumbfounding to me to compare that to the modern engine. It's just incredibly sophisticated.
- veidr 4y agoThe TL;DR of the video is that 5.1 can render foliage (trees/shrubs) better, and that is a significant advance. It's not that it's a bargain, or a good value for the price. The title of the video is "Why Unreal Engine 5.1 is a Huge Deal". Without the word "Huge" it comes across rather differently.
- herendin 4y agoThere's a HN auto filter that removes unnecessary words from titles That could be the cause
- okamiueru 4y agoExpressions like "huge deal", should perhaps be left alone. Either that, or replace both with "significant" or "important". But that too seems silly.
- burntalmonds 4y agoPerhaps? It completely changes the original meaning.
- veidr 4y agoThanks! (Including the descendant commenters.) Wondering about that is why I bothered to comment at all. I assumed there must be some logical-but-not-quite-working reason. :-D
- Aardwolf 4y agoThis are the weird and visible cases of HN's title rewriting algorithm going wrong. I guess the cases where it does the right thing are not noticeable, and that's why I only see the bad cases. Are there examples where HN title rewriting did something good, or cases where before HN did this titles were very bad or clickbaity?
- nailer 4y ago2:20 for the impatient. This really is a huge deal. For gamers: Unreal 5.0 removed the awkward transitions between low and high poly assets, but removing the need for low and high poly assets (called Levels of Detail or 'LOD' s) at all. The engine just works out how many polys are necessary. But 5.0 didn't do this for foliage - so trees and shrubs and forests look crappy when you zoom out. 5.1 does this for foliage. So you can now... See the forest from the trees. (sunglasses emoji)
- morjom 4y agoYou could say you, nailed it, nailer. I saw this video on my youtube recommended and man am I glad they're figuring out how to phase out billboarding. One of my pet peeves in video games is pop-in and billboarding of far objects.
- nailer 4y ago> One of my pet peeves in video games is pop-in and billboarding of far objects. Yep pop-in within natural environments is one of the last big immersion breakers. Fly or climb to what should be a majestic view and suddenly fake-looking trees spoil everything.
- Aardwolf 4y agoThat's one of them for me. A few others are: -visible banding, especially in skies, in some games, which is very possible even with 24 bit color in this types of gradients, sometimes the monitor itself can cause it too. Dithering should fix this (24-bit color dithering should be almost unnoticeable), since banding looks so ugly this would be a great fix. -textures that repeat themselves. Even in some modern games like Cyberpunk 2077, you'll e.g. see a repeated pattern of reflective rain water on road surfaces. Imho, have 2-4 varitions of the same texture and use a pseudorandom pattern to tile them, that completely eliminates this. Even if it's 4x lower resolution to have 4 variations in the same amount of memory it'd look better. -round things (barrels, round tables, a goblet, ...) that look like a blocky polygon instead of a circle, in games with otherwise incredible amounts of details. Either use more triangles, or, I wish these were a thing, quadratic surfaces. In games that are low detail in general this matters less, in those it fits the style. Fix those things, and several immersion breakers would be gone!
- ohgodplsno 4y agoThat's definitely not all it can do. Foliage without pop in and into Nanite is cool, but Nanite still has work to be done on (AFAIK you still cannot deform and animate Nanite assets). Lumen advances to get translucent materials working is massive. Large worlds is super cool. And I can't remember if it's in 5.1 in beta, but it brings a new layering model for complex materials that works better than clear coat (which is the current 2-layer model, like a car with blue paint and a protective layer on top) with many more possibilities. Putting those abilities into the hands of anyone is a massive thing (well, putting all of UE5). I've seen firsthand people with absolutely no experience in gamedev but in other media production get up to speed with building environments in less than a week, complete with animations & all. Making small virtual worlds is available to basically anyone. And yes, the author of the video has a target audience of people who already use Unreal Engine. To these people, 5.1 is pretty damn massive.
- edf13 4y agoThose reflections and lighting effects are incredible!
- gdtfmaster 4y ago5.1 also includes improved DMX Plugin for proper lighting shows, the plugin adds support for DMX over Ethernet (sACN, Art-Net) and allows lighting fixtures based on devices imported via GDTF [1], [2]. [1] http://gdtf.eu/ http://gdtf.eu/ [2] https://gdtf-share.com/ https://gdtf-share.com/
- brookst 4y agoI’m way into DMX and lighting but only familiar with Unreal as a game/3D engine. What kinds of lighting things are people doing with Unreal?
- jasonjamerson 4y agoOne big thing is Virtual Production, where we shoot video in front of large LED screens showing a 3D scene in Unreal. DMX allows seamless integration of live show control lighting with the lighting in Unreal.
- VMtest 4y agois nanite foliage just shader mesh? and https://nitter.it/search?q=%23Stutterstruggle https://nitter.it/search?q=%23Stutterstruggle
- RepAgent 4y agoWhen real time looks this good, low budget CGI movies or TV-series look even better.
- Someone1234 4y agoWhen it is real-time, we may see this get used for live programming too like The Weather Channel or for dynamic animated ads put over whatever you're watching.
- kyriakos 4y agoEvery kind of technology can be abused, doesn't mean progress should stop.
- bick_nyers 4y agoThe Weather Channel and Unreal Engine 4, 4 years ago: https://youtu.be/x2aCSV5zYlA https://youtu.be/x2aCSV5zYlA
- sod 4y agoThere is a stark effort, skill level, art direction and knowing the limits of cgi cliff between good and "slightly off". How else do you explain district 9 from 13 years ago vs e.g. 200 mio. budget black widow from a year ago. Meaning: The best tools in the wrong hands can still produce mediocre results.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoDistrict 9!! Thanks for reminding me about such a funny movie.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoWasn't that Jackson's first big deal?
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sylware 4y agoIf you want to help debug the build of UE5 on native elf/linux, on steam, get the demo of "vein", play it and report back the bugs to help the devs pushing them upstream.
- ArtWomb 4y agoI think it's a big deal because of efficient micropolygons. I know for myself a custom sub-pixel shaded micropolygon renderer running natively on vulkan is what I am looking forward to most for xmas holiday hacking ;) https://advances.realtimerendering.com/s2021/Karis_Nanite_SIGGRAPH_Advances_2021_final.pdf https://advances.realtimerendering.com/s2021/Karis_Nanite_SI... Building a micropolygon rendering pipeline https://www.cs.cmu.edu/afs/cs/academic/class/15418-s12/www/lectures/25_micropolygons.pdf https://www.cs.cmu.edu/afs/cs/academic/class/15418-s12/www/l...
- bitL 4y agoReading the CMU article, how do you actually make it fast? For each frame you need to collect all objects in the scene (for ray traced scenes anything that can be reflected), split them into micropolygons (either from a triangle mesh or from parametric meshes) and then render all this at e.g. 4K. Each of these steps is extremely demanding.
- mastax 4y agoI can't remember the specifics to give you a summary, but this presentation was fascinating: https://youtu.be/eviSykqSUUw https://youtu.be/eviSykqSUUw
- xyzzy_plugh 4y agoSegmentation in CPU is pretty common as there's huge opportunity for caching. It's possible to push segmentation into GPU as an optimization but it might not be worth it if the GPU is busy enough with downstream operations. Even then you still cache the results. I would be surprised if they don't have a dynamic pipeline that can be optimized at runtime.
- Jasper_ 4y agoYou do as much of that offline as possible. The "split them into micropolygons" happens at editor time, along with a search tree that makes it really easy to find them. It's still very demanding! But the goal is that you bake as much of it that you can.
- synergyS 4y agoUnreal is the platform for the metaverse
- MR4D 4y agoI’m curious what Zuckerberg thinks when he sees things like this compared to Meta’s own attempts. The sheer magnitude of the difference has to make him wonder (and if not, shareholders certainly have!)
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoMark isn’t stupid. His metaverse is specifically targeting lower end hardware so it can run on stand alone headsets and so eventually those headsets can be cheap. A lot of the earlier PC Oculus UI was unreal engine anyway.
- andybak 4y agoUnreal is a platform for creating applications. The Meta product you refer to is an application built on such platforms (not Unreal in this case). Meta's app has to run on what is essentially a mobile phone. You can barely run Nanite in VR on desktop let along on a mobile phone. Not saying Meta's product couldn't be better but we are talking "better like Rec Room" not "better like UE5's best efforts"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- air7 4y agoA bit off topic, but are there any free 3D real-time rendered scenes where you can move around that exists just to be pretty/show off the graphics card abilities?
- pippy360 4y agoArchviz (architecture visualization) is very good for this. Just search “ue5 archviz“ on YouTube
- mastax 4y agoThere are a bunch of demos for the unreal engine that you can download. I wanted to try them out recently after I built my new computer but unreal engine crashes every time I launch it. Oh well. Edit: funny, reducing my DDR5 memory speed seems to have fixed unreal engine. New platforms are fun.
- solardev 4y agoYeah, the Ue5 engine comes with a bunch of demos, like a city you can walk around in with a bunch of buildings and cars and streets and such.
- samspenc 4y agoIf you're looking for a raw "benchmark" style program to measure performance of your CPU and GPU for 3D tasks, I highly recommend the open-source Blender Benchmark https://opendata.blender.org/ https://opendata.blender.org/ . It also has a bunch of existing data points for a large number of CPUs and GPUs already.
- Animats 4y agoSome Unreal Engine demos: - 2013 - The Valley [1] A nice, explorable forest with weather. Requires a reasonably powerful PC and graphics card. - 2017 - Superposition.[2] A very detailed lab scene. Requires a good gamer PC. - 2021 - The Valley of the Ancients [3] The first UE5 demo. Requires a really good gamer PC. - 2022 - The Matrix Awakens [4] The high-end UE5 demo. If you have to ask what hardware it requires, you can't afford it. The Valley is from 9 years ago, and it still looks good. Try it first. From a metaverse engineering perspective, hardware requirements limit what you can do. What's possible today is incredibly good. What you can run on the average user's laptop in the browser is way, way below that level. This is the era of the $1000 phone and the $100 laptop. GPU price/performance hasn't improved much in years. NVidia doesn't market anything below US$250 any more, although some old cards are sometimes available. The average Steam user has an NVidia 1060, released in 2016. It cost $250 back then, and it costs about $250 now on Amazon. Yes, there's cloud gaming, where the GPU is in a data center. Now look at the pricing on cloud gaming. Many cloud gaming companies have gone bust, including Google Stadia, because the economics don't work. To get a mass market, you have to sell at a loss. To run at a profit, the pricing looks like Shadow PC. [1] https://benchmark.unigine.com/valley https://benchmark.unigine.com/valley [2] https://benchmark.unigine.com/superposition https://benchmark.unigine.com/superposition [3] https://docs.unrealengine.com/5.0/en-US/valley-of-the-ancient-sample-game-for-unreal-engine/ https://docs.unrealengine.com/5.0/en-US/valley-of-the-ancien... [4] https://www.unrealengine.com/en-US/blog/introducing-the-matrix-awakens-an-unreal-engine-5-experience https://www.unrealengine.com/en-US/blog/introducing-the-matr...
- cainxinth 4y agoThe narrator mispronounces foliage every single time. It has three syllables, not two.
- udp 4y agoThey do the same with “quality” too so I guess it’s just their accent.
- tom_ 4y agoEnglish has a wide range of accents, and correct pronounciation of even common words can vary widely.
- crazygringo 4y agoThat two-syllable pronunciation initially struck me as wrong too, but it turns out: > The disyllabic pronunciation \ˈfō-lij\ is very common. Some commentators insist that foliage requires a trisyllabic pronunciation because of its spelling, but words of a similar pattern such as carriage and marriage do not fall under their prescription. [1] The speaker otherwise has a fairly General American accent, so I'm curious if the two-syllable version is a geographic thing? Unfortunately, it was never included in the Harvard Dialect Survey [2]. [1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/foliage https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/foliage [2] http://dialect.redlog.net/ http://dialect.redlog.net/
- thaumasiotes 4y ago>> The disyllabic pronunciation \ˈfō-lij\ is very common. MW does also note that that pronunciation is nonstandard. I checked the first 20 samples on youglish ( https://youglish.com/pronounce/foliage/english/us https://youglish.com/pronounce/foliage/english/us? ). 16 used an unambiguous three-syllable pronunciation, 3 unambiguously omitted the middle syllable (#9, #16, #22†), and one (#12) was ambiguous. Of the disyllabic pronunciations, only #9 had a marked regional accent. † Why is #22 one of the first 20 samples? Two of the earlier samples are different timestamps into the same video, which I only counted once, and one is missing, which I counted zero times.
- 4y ago
- synergy20 4y agoLove it. It supports ubuntu 22.04 with a 22GB download size. I need find a better desktop with better graphic card to run this I assume, any recommendations?
- sogen 4y agoYou can get an external gpu (eGPU) to keep your current setup. Check the Razer Core X, and add a graphic card of your choice.
- synergy20 4y agoThanks! looks like it only supports windows and macos though.
- Operyl 4y agoThere are numerous posts of people getting it working on Linux, with some caveats: https://y.tsutsumi.io/2020/08/15/egpu-linux-core-x-chroma/ https://y.tsutsumi.io/2020/08/15/egpu-linux-core-x-chroma/
- sogen 4y agoThe egpu forums might be a good resource: https://egpu.io/forums/thunderbolt-linux-setup/ubuntu-19-04-easy-to-use-setup-script-for-your-egpu/paged/13/#post-95763 https://egpu.io/forums/thunderbolt-linux-setup/ubuntu-19-04-...
- jamesfmilne 4y agoRuns fine on Rocky 8.6 as well.
- barbariangrunge 4y agoWhat about the epic launcher to download your marketplace assets or megascans?
- samspenc 4y agoJust FYI, it also needs 200+ GB hard disk space to install, I believe minimum GPU recommendation is Nvidia 2080 (or equivalent) with 4-6 GB GPU VRAM. I've seen posts online where they recommend higher-end chips and much more GPU memory (12+ GB VRAM) for building larger worlds and higher poly resolutions.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoTitle has been mangled to the point that the meaning is gone.
- tomcam 4y agoThat’s a huge deal ;)
- bitL 4y agoIs Unreal 5 now mostly software-rendered in the Nanite mode and only large triangles (>32 pixles diameter) are HW-accelerated?
- Jasper_ 4y agoAnything animated isn't supported as well, only static meshes.
- jiggawatts 4y agoEverything you see made by the Unreal engine is hardware rendered. More and more computations are being offloaded to the GPU over time, not less.
- bitL 4y agoI thought so as well, then I read the Unreal 5 SIGGRAPH 2021 presentation where they stated: "Turns out we can beat the hardware with triangles much bigger than expected, far past micropoly. We software rasterize any clusters whos triangles are less than 32 pixels long."
- xpl 4y agoIt is still done on GPU, you just don't use its builtin triangle rasterizer and do the rasterization yourself using "compute shaders" (programs that run on GPU). It doesn't mean they use CPU for rasterization.
- molszanski 4y agoThis looks like something Euclidian / Unlimited Detail promised 10 years ago
- kelsolaar 4y ago“Euclideon” https://www.euclideon.com/ https://www.euclideon.com/
- barbariangrunge 4y agoYou could actually already preserve the shadows when using billboards in unreal by using distance field shadows