2 ms·
> What if some theories that aren't testable eventually lead to theories that are testable and useful? The history of physics is such that this almost never ha
by adastra22 4y ago
> What if some theories that aren't testable eventually lead to theories that are testable and useful?
The history of physics is such that this almost never happened. In fact I'm struggling to think of an example in which it did, though I'm sure there are some examples somewhere.
The few things I can think of are stuff like antimatter, which popped out of the theory and weren't taken seriously until they were unexpectedly confirmed by experiment.
On the other hand as you mention the history of physics is littered with theories and frameworks pushing beyond the experimental frontier, only to be discarded. String theory being only the most recent example.
- nl 4y agoShe points to both the big bang and the idea of a multiverse as things that cannot be tested.
- adastra22 4y agoWhich is factually correct, no? We cannot see beyond the cosmic microwave background, which post-dates the Big Bang by a significant amount. Barring the development of astronomical scale gravity wave detectors, we probably can’t probe further than the CMB, not directly at least. Things like the ratio of hydrogen to helium allow us to constrain our model of the Big Bang and early inflation, but that is parameter matching on the assumption of a big bang, not evidence for it. That’s a fine but important point. The Big Bang is still the simplest cosmological origin story we have that fits the evidence, and I don’t think Sabine is denying it. Nor does she deny multiverse theories which have even less of a leg to stand on. The case of multiverse theory is even worse as there are no testable predictions which come from them.