4 ms·
It’s sadly unsurprising that the ACLU has taken the opposite position on use of government contracting to achieve that the state cannot do directly when the lib
by rayiner 4y ago
It’s sadly unsurprising that the ACLU has taken the opposite position on use of government contracting to achieve that the state cannot do directly when the liberty at issue is religious rather than speech: https://www.aclupa.org/en/news/what-fulton-v-city-philadelphia-means-lgbqt-families-and-individuals https://www.aclupa.org/en/news/what-fulton-v-city-philadelph...
- Finnucane 4y agoThat case is about letting people use religion as an excuse to discriminate against people they don’t like.
- rayiner 4y agoSpecifically, that case is about governments forcing adoption services to work with gay couples if they want government contracts. Similarly, this case is about governments forcing private businesses to do business with Israelis if they want to get government contracts.
- Finnucane 4y agoThe government can enforce rules against discrimination and religion doesn’t mean you get a free pass from laws you don’t like.
- rayiner 4y agoThere is no anti-discrimination law with respect to adoption services, and it's doubtful such a law would be constitutional. The 14th amendment applies to governments, not individuals. To regulate private conduct, the government needs some other hook. Usually, this is the commerce power, which is the basis of non-discrimination laws in public accommodations or housing. That's why things like private clubs and rentals in owner-occupied buildings are exempt from those laws. In other cases, such as non-discrimination in education, the hook is acceptance of federal funding. The question in both the adoption case and the anti-BDS case is the extent to which the government can use its position as a purchaser to control otherwise legal private conduct.