4 ms·
I should take a look at DevonThink (and maybe Obsidian though I'm mostly fine with Google Docs). I own Scrivener and have used it. But I don't find it ideal for
by ghaff 4y ago
I should take a look at DevonThink (and maybe Obsidian though I'm mostly fine with Google Docs). I own Scrivener and have used it. But I don't find it ideal for research materials and, for the non-fiction writing I do, I don't find functional flow all that complicated. And then I'm going to have to transfer it to a different tool at some point anyway.
Scrivener seems like it's good at solving problems I mostly don't feel I have.
- rcarr 4y agoOnce you get it set up how you want it, DevonThink absolutely rocks and it’s perfect for non-fiction research. It’s got a 100 hour free trial so worth testing it out. I’d recommend downloading the manual and/or the Take Control Of DevonThink book from the devontechnologies website (both free) and giving both a speed read so you get an idea of some of the stuff it can do. Obviously depends on your own individual workflow but here are some of my recommendations: Make sure you get the iOS companion app DevonThink To Go. This allows you to capture everything on your mobile devices. Also make sure you install all add ons via DevonThink3 -> Install Add Ons. These add ons will: - Allow you to view and import emails in DevonThink (you will also have to enable the plugin in the Apple Mail app for this functionality to work) - Put an ‘Inbox’ folder in your finder which allows you to just drag any file or folder into it and have it appear in your DevonThink Inbox - Give you OCR for all your pdfs - Give you extensions for browsers to clip things easily. When you clip something that you want to read or refer back to you’re generally best off using the ‘paginated PDF’ setting as not all the available options support annotation and the AI search. It’s not a big deal if you don’t because you can just right click something and click ‘Convert To’ to turn it into a pdf later. Two settings I’d recommend trying out: DevonThink3 -> Preferences -> General -> Interface -> Retain View (On) Stops the view from changing every time you switch databases which can be annoying. DevonThink3 -> Preferences -> General -> Interface -> Unify Inboxes (Off) Moves each databases inbox into the database itself which makes it a lot easier for when you’re filing things. Four Shortcuts I Find Useful: Cmd-Ctrl-M - brings up a panel for moving a file quickly Cmd-7 for wide screen view (makes more sense than the standard view) Cmd-option-i - toggle right inspector Cmd-option-1 - toggle left sidebar
- ghaff 4y agoThanks! Working on a shortish tech history book right now for which I don't have the research especially well organized--and am in the process of refactoring. This will make a good test case.
- rcarr 4y agoNo worries. One more thing you might be interested in, they also do another app called DevonAgent that allows you to do deep dive searches across different search engines at the same time including academic paper search engines. You can also use boolean operators on the search terms as well as advanced search terms such near, before, after etc as in 'term1 near\n term2' which would run a search looking for term1 within n words of term2. You can then import the results directly into devonthink for further processing. Very cool stuff.
- stereoradonc 4y agoWhere do you have time to read with this level of complexity!
- rcarr 4y agoLol it's really not as bad as it sounds, just jump in and start using it and your workflow will spontaneously emerge
- theuseus 4y agoTry UpNote, I find it more usable than Obsidian,
- rcarr 4y agoJust had a look at it. It's ok but there are some serious limitations in comparison to Obsidian which would make it unsatisfactory for me: - No command palette - No block inclusion - Notes appear to be stored in databases rather than just as markdown notes on the file system. Backup of markdown notes seems to create a flat group of folders with randomly generated file names. - No plugin/extension capability. - No graph view - No daily note template support
- theuseus 4y agoYeah, that's an issue, but for me, it felt more like an app rather than a wrapper. And the table support is way superior to Obsidian.