7 ms·
We Built a Meta Pixel Inspector
- Hydraulix989 4y agoI wish more energy was directed to also understanding what data Google and TikTok collect from their users.
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: Tax filing websites have been sending users’ financial information to Facebook - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33705532 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33705532 - Nov 2022 (74 comments) Tax-filing websites have been sending users financial info to Meta - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33753058 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33753058 - Nov 2022 (18 comments)
- tobr 4y agoCould you add back the “How” in the title?
- elmomle 4y agoThis is great and important work. I think it would be substantially more approachable if it began with an "Abstract" or "Summary" section. Like it or not, most folks just want the headlines; the presentation of the details is only important if people understand and care about the core ideas. tl;dr for the website: meta pixels are everywhere on the web and gathering your interactions and inputs on all kinds of sites--including ones related to your guilty pleasures, your taxes, your health, school, etc.
- N3Xxus_6 4y agoI actually work in an industry that utilizes these a lot. Google, tiktok, meta etc. I implement the code on our customers sites. It's crazy how much data these scripts collect.
- glitchcrab 4y ago> It's crazy how much data these scripts collect And you're ok with this?
- paulcole 4y agoIs your question rhetorical? Their actions tell us they’re OK with it.
- dylan604 4y agoDo they? Have you never done something under protest?
- luckylion 4y agoDevelopers doing something "under protest"? Why would they? Nobody is going hungry if they don't work at $corp any more and work for $otherCorp instead. That'll be something for when the market has fundamentally changed and you'll make your nation's average for your education level. But until then essentially nobody has to work anywhere "under protest", there are so many other opportunities.
- dylan604 4y agoSo says you in a market where bigTech is laying people off, where people have spouse/kids/house payment/car payment/holiday pressures/adult responsibilites. Choice A) stand on principle and ruffle feathers and risk becoming unemployed Choice B) just do what tasks you've been assigned, collect paycheck, hold your nose until better options are available. It is totally understandable why people can find themselves in these situations. It is totally different than the team member that thinks up this stuff and actively promotes this within the org. Those are the asshats
- luckylion 4y agoOther options have been available since forever and still are unless you're in a super niche field, and everything that touches ads and tracking / analytics isn't niche. There's more than enough work out there, but those other jobs might not net an individual 10x the average household income. Can one survive on 5x or even 3x? Then there are more than enough alternatives. If the employer has kidnapped your daughter and threatens to kill her if you don't build this tracking solution, then I can totally see how you'd do things you find reprehensible "under protest". But I doubt that's a common scenario, and generally people just don't care or they rationalize it ("I'm working on ads so the internet will not be paywalled").
- mind-blight 4y agoThe article claims that the meta pixel can load JavaScript. Does anyone know if/how that's possible? I can't think of a way using an image alone would trigger downloading JS
- smelendez 4y agoIt’s not a literal pixel and hasn’t been for years – it’s a js file included from a Meta site. They still call it the pixel for some reason, maybe to make it seem less potent.
- iamacyborg 4y agoI think they just used to call it the “like” button
- schemescape 4y agoI think it’s a snippet of JavaScript code and not an “img” tag, despite the name.
- itishappy 4y ago> The Meta Pixel gets its name from trackers that traditionally took the form of small, one-pixel-by-one-pixel images. These tiny graphics are embedded on websites and emails and typically collect info on who views the content. Since the Meta Pixel’s first iteration over a decade ago, when it was called the Facebook Conversion Pixel, the pixel’s functionality and tracking have grown quite expansive. Now the Meta Pixel is a mechanism that loads JavaScript code capable of collecting detailed and granular data for every interaction on a page. With all of this complexity, referring to it as only a “pixel” can be misleading.
- blooalien 4y agoFor those who are unaware how this all fits together, the literal pixel's purpose is to ensure that even if Javascript is entirely disabled on the client (end-user) system, there is still a log entry at the tracker's end of things noting a time/date and IP address of document access. This is then fairly easily correlated with other logged data to further flesh out the profile of the user that data leads back to. This even works across domains, without actually visiting Facebook or Google, allowing them to still track that you've visited a site where their pixel is used, and the time/date/IP of that access. It's just one small part of their whole tracking toolbox, and the pixel itself is merely an image file, and unable to in and of itself load any Javascript. Still doesn't stop 'em from using it to track you… Only way to do that is to block Javascript and never access the pixel image itself as well. Of course, then they track you through other means…
- spikefromspace 4y agoAlso note that they allow for server side data as well so companies can send via backends and circumvent any ad blockers. Good companies do respect a users preferences but not all do.
- luckylion 4y agoYou need some syncing though, otherwise Facebook wouldn't know who that user is that almost bought your stuff and that you now want to retarget.
- dwild 4y agoFacebook could probably just ask to send whatever you got about the user and they'll deal with the identification. User agent + IP is probably more than enough. Worst case they just build a JS that can be included and give the full fingerprint.
- tppiotrowski 4y agoWhat's the mechanism here? I thought it's sharing a cross domain cookie that allows you to identify a user as they surf from one domain to another.
- nerdponx 4y agoFingerprinting?
- luckylion 4y agoYou click on a tracking link, Server 1 now has a unique ID associated with that click. S1 forwards you to S2 with a unique identifier. S2 now has that unique ID associated with you. You buy something on S2. S2 sends a request to S1 saying "unique ID #123 bought something for $40".
- spikefromspace 4y agoFingerprinting and tracking links are common for unindentified users. Cross domain cookies are harder to fo outside of chrome. For known users, you can sync data to Facebook with email addresses, names, phone numbers etc. This is likely why you see most websites these days trying to collect that info from you as early as possible.
- marketingtech 4y agoMeta offers their own...it's not hidden. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/facebook-pixel-helper/fdgfkebogiimcoedlicjlajpkdmockpc?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/facebook-pixel-hel... But this doesn't cover server-side data transfer. https://developers.facebook.com/docs/marketing-api/conversions-api/ https://developers.facebook.com/docs/marketing-api/conversio...
- Xelynega 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but the tool in the OP sounds like a crowdsourcing effort to collect the data the Facebook tool can tell you across multiple users and multiple sites. That's not really the same thing as a tool that tells a single person that the site they're on uses meta pixel as it happens.
- kripy 4y agoCorrect. The Facebook Pixel Helper is used to test that the pixel has been installed correctly and events, both standard and custom, are firing correctly.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoIs it still safe to assume that uBlock Origin blocks all of this?
- lostmsu 4y agoNo, I got majority of my history in https://www.facebook.com/off_facebook_activity https://www.facebook.com/off_facebook_activity
- tppiotrowski 4y agoMy privacy stance has evolved to just assume everything I do online is public. Even if we fight and succeed in stopping a tracking mechanism (third-party cookies) we discover that another one is developed (fingerprinting). It's times when you think you have privacy/no one is watching that you're most susceptible to doing something you might regret. If you consciously acknowledge that your digital life is public, you can consider performing activities using other mediums. Calling instead of messaging. Shopping at stores with cash. Journaling in a paper notebook.
- mulligan 4y agoI think these folks fail to connect the pixel with its purpose. The sites and apps who advertise want to understand who is converting, they provide this information to the advertiser so they can correlate the users who saw an ad to a purchase. By keeping the purpose vague, it makes it seem nefarious.
- Xelbair 4y agothe actual purpose IS nefarious.
- vorpalhex 4y agoI'll give you $5 if you give me access to your email account in full and let me see what you buy, what newsletters you sign up for, etc. I won't even steal any of your data or anything nefarious outside of collect some stats for my own uses. If you let Facebook do this for free, you should at least take the $5 from me.
- zaptheimpaler 4y agoI went to look at the off-site facebook history on my profile. Its truly scary the amount of data they have. The worst part is this: https://imgur.com/a/A8JVQOR https://imgur.com/a/A8JVQOR So Mozilla, which is one of the companies behind the effort to understand the Meta Pixel, is also sending data to Facebook? I was not a member of the Rally study. What the f** is going on? Is Firefox itself tracking me too? Or maybe some extension? Which extension? How am i supposed to tell without hoping that the right person magically sees this comment or going 100% technical and running packet captures and Wireshark? Why can't we just get access to the _RAW_ data being sent or stored about us? As of now, VS Code will send encrypted data to Microsoft when you use it. So my machine, OS, applications all send data about me to companies, and I'm not even allowed to know what it is (not to single them out, VS Code is just one example I have inspected myself). I don't claim to understand SSL all that well, but i think they used certificate pinning and pre-master secrets that makes it impossible or very difficult for anyone outside MS to decrypt the data in any way... This is all completely normal now. On mobile devices its even worse. Its not even possible to completely inspect the data a phone/tablet sends without rooting it and many are already impossible to bootloader unlock or root/jailbreak. With certificate pinning, on an encrypted smartphone volume with a hardware key, that is only unlocked just in time by the OS (the way android works now), it is LITERALLY impossible to know what data is being transmitted or received over SSL on your own device. You are not allowed to know.
- Tsiklon 4y agoPerhaps more generously, to Firefox, they’re interpreting Firefox user strings as an app sending data to them. For curiosity, where did you pull that data from?
- SirSavary 4y agoSee https://www.facebook.com/off_facebook_activity https://www.facebook.com/off_facebook_activity
- jkaplowitz 4y agoWhat's the equivalent for people who don't have Facebook accounts? I presume data about me has been sent to Facebook despite that fact.
- ranting-moth 4y agoDoes Firefox's Enhanced Tracking Protection block this properly? https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/enhanced-tracking-protection-firefox-desktop https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/enhanced-tracking-prote...
- eulgro 4y agoToo bad this isn't about the OTCA metapixel... https://conwaylife.com/wiki/OTCA_metapixel https://conwaylife.com/wiki/OTCA_metapixel
- alasdair_ 4y agoThe thing that really got me, personally, was searching psychologytoday.com for a mental health professional and seeing that Facebook had a copy of everything I'd searched for, without me ever agreeing to any kind of data sharing. [disclaimer: I worked at Facebook at the time. I was still appalled.]