4 ms·
It's incredibly important NEVER to reveal information visually before you get to talking about it. With scrolling, you'll be showing bits of the "next topic/poi
by crazygringo 4y ago
It's incredibly important NEVER to reveal information visually before you get to talking about it. With scrolling, you'll be showing bits of the "next topic/points" at the bottom of the screen (unless you're incredibly careful) and people will be paying attention to that and guessing what comes next rather than paying attention to the discussion. (Don't know why people do, they just do. People are curious and easily distracted.)
Therefore, you need a fixed canvas to flip through, for total control. Hence, fixed slides rather than scrolling.
This is also why when slides have multiple main bullet points, it's very common to only reveal them one bullet at a time. This ensures you have the audience's attention as you discuss each one, and their mind isn't distracted by thinking about the next.
So that's the main reason -- to carefully and precisely control the flow of information, to sync talking/discussion with the visual.
Secondarily, slides lend themselves to attractive layout of images etc. for maximum effect of storytelling and emotional effect. Of course, for a highly technical presentation, that may be irrelevant. But a lot of talks do include a storytelling/emotional aspect where the dramatic framing of a single photo is important, which you need a slide with a fixed layout to do.
- blindseer 4y agoI’m not saying you are wrong, I’ve done the same thing, although I’ve started to think more deeply about how and when to reveal content. Edward Tufte on the other hand suggests never “revealing” content since he claims that’s treating the audience not intelligently.
- throwup 4y agoIf I'm listening to a speaker, I'm there to learn. If I knew everything already, I wouldn't be wasting my time. So my intelligence is not insulted if the speaker assumes I don't know things.
- tux3 4y agoIt's possible to tell people new information with or without misjudging their capacity to follow, and with or without being boring. All those combinations happen out there. Just like a book or a movie, your audience has to be able to notice that you're taking them somewhere, without being able to piece the whole picture together until the reveal. If you circle around a concept for a while, slowly inch towards it, and press the Next button on your remote like the grand unveiling of a marble statue, the reveal better be worth the buildup. The other extreme exists as well. Make it too cryptic, and people will have no idea what your point is. No one appreciates having to wait through the slow exposition of something they already figured out. Spend too long revealing something you've already given away, and people will sleep through your snazzy powerpoint reveal transition FX. You want presentations to be entertaining because people remember information they're interested in! It's not showmanship for the sole sake of the dazzle. Get people's attention, and your slides stick.
- sophacles 4y agoI already knew all this. How dare you tell me about it as if it was new?
- tsuujin 4y ago> No one appreciates having to wait through the slow exposition of something they already figured out. It’s common for people to rewatch movies they have already seen, and reread books they have already read. Sometimes the joy is in the presentation, not the destination.
- kthejoker2 4y agoDid Tufte say that regarding live presentations? As he's more of an infographic / dashboard SME. Live presentations are designed to "lead the witness" (neither inherently good nor bad) - or rather, if a presentation really is merely a collection of things without a narrative, it might as well obey Tufte and lay it out all at once.
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 4y agoHe sure hates PowerPoint with a passion.
- amichail 4y agoWhy can't you reveal items one by one in a scrollable document just like you do in slides?
- Jtsummers 4y agoOnce you do, why not just use slides since you're recreating the experience and using them in the same manner?
- macintux 4y agoYou can, but at that point it’s much easier to break it up by slide, at least with the tooling we have that’s targeted at giving such presentations.
- spoiler 4y agoWould you pad the pages? How would you know what's enough padding depending on screen proprtions/rotation during presentation? How do you align the "scroll step" to match your presentation padding? If you address all of these, I think you end up with something that looks like a presentation, but the panels have a "slide up" animation/transition to simulate scrolling. So I guess this slide transition could end up being a compromise for people who really want that effect
- cperciva 4y agoIf you're scrolling a document, the most recently revealed line is always at the bottom, which is often the least visible part of the screen if you have a large audience.
- shagie 4y agoYou can, however unless you've got significant padding, the previous information that is scrolled up (but still visible) is still there and possibly distracting. If you are padding sufficiently to have only the content that you want visible at one time, you've got a slide - and other tooling is better for presenting slides.
- xattt 4y agoRevealing information ahead of time seems counterintuitive when sone presentations have handouts distributed beforehand.
- Arainach 4y agoGood presentations generally don't do this. Distributing handouts/printed slides is a symptom of a culture of bad presentations (bad as in a waste of everyone's time), just like paragraphs of text on a slide that the presenter reads verbatim.
- fbdab103 4y agoHard disagree. Always provide me maximum information. If there is a chance I can pre-consume some of the content, I am more likely to better follow what the speaker is presenting and learn more than if everything is fresh. Audience can choose to not do the pre-reading (most will not), but for those who want it, allows for deeper appreciation of the talk.
- jghn 4y agoIt depends on the context. For example, with business meetings slides tend to be jam packed with information. They're already a glorified document with a narrator. The speaker is there to enhance the slides. It works well to hand those out ahead of time. For a proper presentation, like at a conference, IMO slides should be there to supplement the speaker. Not the other way around. Thus the amount of hard information on the slides themselves should be minimal. Because of this, hand outs don't make as much sense. And of course a third angle. If one follows my philosophy for conference talks & such, then there's the problem that distributing slides after the fact are useless, because all the important information was conveyed by the speaker. But that's another discussion altogether.
- fbdab103 4y agoBy sheer number, the majority of presentations are of the business-disseminate information type, so that's my default angle. Unless there is some big reveal that requires secrecy, it costs nothing to pre-share slides, so I wish it were more common.
- skmurphy 4y agoA slide is not a text transcript. Revealing one bullet at a time assumes the atomic element in a presentation is the bullet. I think it's the slide, which is often an image or a diagram. You earn the audience's attention for the next slide by what you have said for the last. In addition, a TED talk is not a good model for an effective briefing. An effective presentation is interactive and allows for questions to affect the flow. This is especially true for sales presentations, but any presentation where you are trying to move an audience to action.