4 ms·
I don't have an opinion, but I'll say that the argument form of "no normal person wants to do X; if you want to do X, there's something wrong with you" should b
by stavros 4y ago
I don't have an opinion, but I'll say that the argument form of "no normal person wants to do X; if you want to do X, there's something wrong with you" should be beneath us.
I hope we know better than casual No True Scotsman arguments.
- recuter 4y agoI'd just like to thank you, as a (cannibal) resident of Nukuhiva, for respecting my culture. Everything is just a matter of perspective after all, it is good to keep an open mind.
- stavros 4y agoI guess maybe I should adjust the standard of discourse I expect on HN.
- terryf 4y agoThe other guy is right. Moral relativism is not the way. There are limits to acceptance as you imply in your comment. Freedom is measurable and matters. How long is the list of things that you can do for which the state can repress you in Saudi Arabia? How long is the list in Belgium? Is there a fair trial process? Are there equal rights to people? Yes, some people want to cover their faces and that is fine. Some others don't. That should be fine as well.
- stavros 4y agoNo, both of you are strawmanning my argument. I said "No True Scotsman isn't a valid argument" and you got "moral relativism is OK" from that. There's a vast difference between "saying 'no sane person wants to do X, therefore if you want to do X, you're insane' is wrong" and "everything is morally OK".
- recuter 4y agoSo, presumably there is a line after all. I'm not sure what we are disagreeing with other than palatable phrasing. I submit that cannibalism is somewhere over the line and I also agree that 'no sane person would want to be eaten alive' could be considered unfortunate phrasing. But how would you phrase it better?
- stavros 4y agoIt's not about whether there's a line or not, it's about the phrasing setting the goalposts in such a way that it's a circular argument that can't be argued against. Nobody can say anything because your argument is "if you want to do this, you're bad, because you want to do this". A better argument would be "this is bad because it doesn't respect the autonomy of women", instead of "this is bad because bad people do it, and the people who do it are bad because they do it". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman
- recuter 4y agoBut this is easy to argue against: > No normal, rational human being would want to cover their face. You could say that some women do it willingly out of piety by buying into the cultural mores they grew up in. That from their perspective women who don't do so are crazy and debase themselves. Or throw the no true scotsman fallacy at them as you did. Technically, you've won the argument... ..unfortunately I can't be sure you're not accidentally straw-manning (why can't it be straw personing! As a scarecrow I am offended :P) the person you were replying to. I say accidentally because I know you to always argue in good faith. And to be fair it is ambiguously and poorly phrased as you say. But lets extend this same good faith to the rest of their sentence: > If they do, then it means they’re raised that way and brainwashed. > Or they’re straight up lying, for fear of prosecution. I think that is the very heart of the matter. Can't speak for the op and whether they meant to make that point but my reading of their full argument is: "this is not only bad because bad people do it, but mostly because the bad people gas-light everybody about their culture and piety and the majority of women have to pretend to go along with it willingly". No true scotsman obviously doesn't apply to, say, a situation like North Korea. Anyway, I don't like the woke-y phrasings either but lets not be so open minded as to have our brains fall out. Even a broken clock is right twice a day. ;) When it comes to SA they happen to be correct.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoMoral realism is not the way. There is absolutely no reason to believe in universal right and wrong. Might make you feel good but that doesn’t make it true
- terryf 4y agoYou sure seem to be absolute in that belief ;)
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI try to stay epistemically humble. As far as meta-ethics go I tend to lean toward proving a positive as opposed to a negative which is why I am a relativist in the face of no proof.
- bitcharmer 4y agoThis refers to your comments more than others. There's a lot of mental gymnastics you're engaging in.
- akudha 4y agoWhy don’t you have an opinion? They’re treating women so bad, their policies are stuck in 1200s, and we are in 2022. Does that not bother you at least a bit? Honest question about the argument - how would you phrase it (I wrote that comment)?
- stavros 4y agoI wouldn't make that argument that way, I'd say I don't like what they're doing. It's not useful to say "no normal being would do that", given that millions of "normal" human beings do it. It makes it sound like they're inhuman monsters and that we'd never do that. The truth is, if you and I were raised there, we probably would, just like we eat meat.
- akudha 4y agoOk, fair enough. The truth is, if you and I were raised there, we probably would But that is kinda what I said though, isn’t it? Anyway, I wasn’t trying to make them sound like monsters (except the rulers, they sure are). I’ll try to word things better, next time.
- stavros 4y agoIt's not so much about the wording, it's about this line of argumentation separating us from them. I especially dislike this line of thinking when thinking about Nazi Germany and the atrocities there, because people tend to think "no sane person would do that, and we're sane, so we won't do it". Instead, a much better line of thinking is "normal people can do this, under specific circumstances, so we should be very careful not to fall into the same trap ourselves".