4 ms·
The difference between music and AI art is that music is still made by humans. The music industry currently has a monopoly on producing new music, so of course
by athrowaway12 4y ago
The difference between music and AI art is that music is still made by humans. The music industry currently has a monopoly on producing new music, so of course they have leverage to get paid for that new music.
- jfk13 4y agoSurely someone is busy training a model on a million pop songs. Why wouldn't "AI music" work very much like "AI art"?
- athrowaway12 4y agoNot yet though. In the future, for sure. My point is that Napster-to-SD is not a fair comparison. Napster didn't eliminate or replace human artists, while SD certainly did. Therefore, it's not fair to assume the government can regulate themselves out of this one like they did with Napster. Because even though Napster enabled widespread piracy, the human musicians still had leverage in that they were needed to create new music. So my answer to the question posed by parent comment of "will SD play out the same way that Napster did?" is "no" because there are fundamentally different economics at play. Obviously, if a good generative model comes out, the music industry will be in a similar boat to the art industry right now. Google was working on it in 2017 (https://magenta.tensorflow.org/performance-rnn https://magenta.tensorflow.org/performance-rnn) but I don't know if they've made any progress since.