6 ms·
For emulating vintage gaming hardware that's no longer available, one argument would be preservation of the media. But what's the rationale (not rationalizatio
by neilv 4y ago
For emulating vintage gaming hardware that's no longer available, one argument would be preservation of the media.
But what's the rationale (not rationalization) on running an emulation of the Nintendo Switch, when it's still commercially available?
In practice, is it usually because people want to play the games without paying for the hardware and software?
- asveikau 4y agoPreservation starts in the present, does it not? I think one thing that's easy to forget, some of the old school emulation, like early SNES emulators, came about when the hardware was still kinda current or recent.
- eru 4y agoYes, the timelines match up pretty well: The SNES was released in Japan in 1990. The first SNES emulator in 1994 could run a few homebrews; I'd say SNES emulation proper started in perhaps 1996 with Snes96, but that's a judgement call. The Switch was released in 2017. We are in 2022 now.
- asveikau 4y agoNice observation. I hadn't realized how parallel that timeline is. I just remember playing games on a pentium 2 in '98 that were published in '94.
- roywiggins 4y agoAnd Nintendo 64 was released 1996-7, UltraHLE was 1999. And apparently early GBA emulation predated the GBA? https://emulation.fandom.com/wiki/History_of_emulation#Game_Boy_Advance https://emulation.fandom.com/wiki/History_of_emulation#Game_...
- Vanit 4y agoiirc GBA emulation got an early head start due to leaked documentation (citation needed).
- anyfoo 4y agoFor the developer community, I think it's mostly in the challenge and the joy of solving it. For the player community... I have a Switch, and I have zero desire to play my Switch games on anything but the Switch. After all, I already totally accept its reduced performance for its amazing convenience and controller situation. But I do appreciate the preservation aspect. (Seriously, it's not just about handheld vs. docked. Just propping up my Switch, screen only, on a table or the edge of my couch, and playing with relaxed arms and a joy con in each hand, is already worth a ton to me.)
- eru 4y agoYes, and the OLED version of the Switch finally also comes with a proper latch to prop it up.
- anyfoo 4y agoYes! I just replaced my old Switch with the OLED one. At first I was wondering whether it would be a worthwhile upgrade, but I can now say, for me specifically at least, would do it again in a heartbeat. That screen is amazing, and the kickstand replacement is so much better…
- gavinsyancey 4y agoI own a Nintendo Switch, and several games for it. I also own a Steam Deck, and I'd like to be able to play my Switch games on it so I don't have to carry two devices around. Emulation lets me do so.
- RockRobotRock 4y agoYes. Piracy is a thing people do sometimes. We can beat around the bush and grandstand or be honest about it.
- bakugo 4y agoIf the emulator has good compatibility for the game you want to play, it's just a much better experience overall. Why play games at low resolutions and unstable framerates when an emulator can run them better at whatever resolution you want, on the same device you already use for most other things? And yes, many people just don't want to pay for the game or console, and there's nothing wrong with that. It's not like Nintendo cares about the customer either anyway.
- wbobeirne 4y agoI don't think feeling snubbed by a business entitles you to their wares without paying, and the law would tend to agree with that.
- PaulBGD_ 4y agoPlaying an emulator requires you to grab the keys from your purchased switch, and dump your games. I’m not going to pretend that a lot of people don’t do this, but this is how it’s recommended to use the emulator.
- skissane 4y agoEven of those who don't, some of them may still have paid for the game they are downloading. Dumping the keys/games from your Switch requires hacking it, and some people are hesitant about doing that (you might brick your Switch, or Nintendo might ban it from their online services.) Or, you might only own a recent revision–which are far more difficult to hack than the first revisions were.
- bakugo 4y agoI never claimed I was legally entitled to it. They're free to stop me, if they can.
- anyfoo 4y agoI disagree with the “better experience” overall. The massive advantage of the Switch is its convenience and form factor. I have a bunch of games that I could play with much better graphics on the versions bought from Steam that I also own, and I still vastly prefer to do so on the Switch.
- xatnys 4y agoI default to the Switch in many cases due to emulation not being compatible in ways that could be significant depending on the game. But if a game plays well on yuzu or ryujinx? Even setting aside better graphical fidelity, the massive increase in sound quality playing on a Steam Deck compared to the Switch makes it absolutely worth it. If I can get away with playing my games on better hardware, I will.
- Marsymars 4y agoI’m years behind on games, but if I have the choice to play an older (say, SNES) game on a PC emulator or on the Wii U (my newest console) Virtual Console, the PC emulator quality of life is miles better, even though I don’t particularly care about graphics. I don’t have the time to spend hours grinding at games any more, but on an emulator, I can play every game with my preferred xbox elite controller, and map save state/load state/fast forward to paddles on the controller. It basically eliminates replaying of areas in games due to difficulty, since save/load-state makes death near-impossible, and any parts of the game that are progressing too slowly I can run at 10x speed.
- daniel-thompson 4y agoGaming PCs can be much more powerful than dedicated consoles these days. For example, Zelda BOTW on Switch is limited to at most 1600x900, but folks running it on their own machines with Cemu can run it at 4k. Some folks also like to try out custom shaders, mods, texture packs, etc. Example: Mario Kart 8 in 4k / raytraced - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OIGpt26ocWU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OIGpt26ocWU
- anyfoo 4y agoWhat’s the point of Breath of the Wild at 4k?!
- m-p-3 4y agoYou can run it at higher than 30fps as well, although with some issues. It does make a difference in smoothness.
- anyfoo 4y agoEveryone’s different, but to me it does not seem worth giving up the convenience of the Switch.
- tazard 4y agoHow about the steam deck then?
- anyfoo 4y agoTempting, but part of the draw of the Switch for me is its controller situation. I often play it propped up with the Joycons detached, one in each hand. Steam deck I would always have to hold in my hands, and can it be docked then? I’ve thought about getting one, but I have a feeling the games that I want to play on a computer instead of my Switch won’t benefit.
- 4y ago
- rrix2 4y agoI don't want to buy a new Switch, but I'm happy to buy games. I have one of the first Switches which have a bootloader exploit and a screen that got scratched up by the dock and both joycons with a nasty analog stick drift. With Ryujinx and yuzu, I buy switch-exclusive games from eShop or the local games shop, dump them to my NAS, and stick them on my steamdeck and the machine whose display the nintendo switch dock used to be attached to. I've bought a lot more games from Nintendo once I was able to use my decent xbox controller, PC, etc, since I started doing this.
- prmoustache 4y agoThe nintendo switch is quite a fragile machine. Mine was already repaired twice. So having a second option if it ends up unrepairable is a good thing imho. Nintendo won't refund my games if my switch die.
- highwaylights 4y agoI think this may be an overly cynical take - there are already exploits / tools that would allow direct piracy on the Switch itself which would no doubt perform much better than any emulation. It seems far more likely that this is done just for the curiosity of doing it. There’s one fascinating outcome to me as a result of Nintendo essentially repeating two hardware generations (GameCube -> Wii, then Wii U -> Switch), which is that on the highest end gaming PCs, games for the Switch can and do run at much higher resolutions and framerates than the Switch itself is capable of. On the YouTube videos I’ve seen the games don’t appear as stable as native hardware, but they really do look tremendous. Especially Breath of the Wild.
- ShamelessC 4y agoPeople regularly pirate and violate licensing agreements without even the mildest cognitive dissonance despite knowing it is breaking the law or unethical.
- account42 4y agoUnethical? Because someone could have profited more?
- ShamelessC 4y agoSure, whatever. That isn't the point.
- cassianoleal 4y agoI have dumped a few of my Switch games to play on the Steam Deck. It's a better experience overall, for the games that run well, and it means I can take only one console when I'm out. I haven't downloaded a single pirate ROM since I own both the hardware and the software. On a powerful PC, you can run some games at much better frame rates than on the Switch hardware as well.