4 ms·
This is a horrible way to avoid upgrading the world to IPv6.
by immibis 4y ago
This is a horrible way to avoid upgrading the world to IPv6.
- Animats 4y agoI'm surprised that Cloudflare isn't all IPv6 when Cloudflare is the client. That would solve their address problems. Maybe charge more if your servers can't talk IPv6. Or require it for the free tier. It's useful that they use client side certificates. (They call this "authenticated origin pull", but it seems to be client side certs.
- ec109685 4y agoThey also have to egress to third party servers since they are a CDN and support things like serverless functions
- amluto 4y agoSadly Cloudflare seems to treat client certificates as an optional nifty feature as opposed to the critical feature that it is. And even some of the settings that look secure aren’t: https://medium.com/@ss23/leveraging-cloudflares-authenticated-origin-pulls-for-pentesting-565c562ef1bb https://medium.com/@ss23/leveraging-cloudflares-authenticate... Authenticated origin pulls should not be “useful”. They should be on and configured securely by default, and any insecure setting should get a loud warning.
- xPaw 4y agoI have tried using cloudflare's client certificate, but it doesn't play well with nginx ssl cache due to increased size on a relatively high load website.
- majke 4y agoHi there! In the article I only briefly mentioned IPv6, it was long enough. Indeed, we do happy-eyeballs where we can and _strongly_ prefer IPv6 when origin host resolves AAAA. However, we still need IPv4, since there is still a big chunk of traffic that only works IPv4. If the client gives us a chance, we'll strongly prefer IPv6.
- xnyan 4y agoThe industry will not transition to v6 unless: 1) The cost of not doing so is higher than the cost of sticking with v4. Because of all the numerous clever tricks and products designed to mitigate v4's limitations, the cost argument still favors v4 for most people in most situations. or 2) We admit that v6 needs to be rethought and rethink it. I understand why v6 does not just increase IP address bits from 32 to 128, but at this point I think everyone has admitted that v6 is simply too difficult for most IT departments to implement. In particular, the complexity of the new assignment schemes like prefix delegation and SLAAC needs to be paired back. Offer a minimum set of features and spin off everything else.
- anecdotal1 4y agoThat and I have PTSD from IPv6 routing to random places being broken which nobody notices because the fallback to v4 is still working ...
- immibis 4y agoBoth prefix delegation and SLAAC are optional. Use DHCPv6 if you like.
- xnyan 4y agoIf they are not needed for core functionally, why are they part of the standard? It's not just IT departments not able to grok v6 that's the problem, IPv6 implementations are a total crapshoot in terms of quality. Some are great, a small few are terrible or straight up don't work at all, and way too many perform perfectly in common situations but blow up in an uncommon edge case. A significant number of devices (especially in industrial, healthcare and scientific fields) still don't support it at all. This both is caused by and perpetuates lack of adoption on the user side. Reduction in scope and complexity makes it easier to implement high quality IPv6 stacks. We also need more high-quality reference implementations available for newer and underserved platforms, but that's a different subject.
- tempnow987 4y agoSome quick questions. SLAAC seems to introduce insane churn in the IPv6 of end user devices. SLAAC (vs DHCPv6) seems to struggle in fully configuring an end user device (think DNS servers etc. As someone who has beat my head on the IPv6 thing for a bit before giving up (I tried to go all IPv6), what is the "proper" way to setup a home IPv6 network with SLAAC and not DHCPv6? If DHCPv6 for some reason is essentially always required, why not let subsume SLAAC for IP address assignments?
- LinkLink 4y agoIt is easier to convince a group of geniuses of a grand idea, than to convince an average person of changing one thing.