3 ms·
It’s really just supply and demand. There aren’t enough homes and landlords know it. If there are 2 families for every home you’re gonna have a bad time, no way
by HDThoreaun 4y ago
It’s really just supply and demand. There aren’t enough homes and landlords know it. If there are 2 families for every home you’re gonna have a bad time, no way around it. Only solution is building more.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIn the case of housing, the tight timeframes for buyers and the low opportunity costs for sellers do not allow for a “fair” playing field. If sellers collude, they can hold out for a few months or even a year without a problem. But buyers are rarely in that position. Technically, it is a supply and demand issue, but the feedback loop takes so long that it needs some other force to keep it humming long term without sellers pushing society to the brink of disaster.
- SSchick 4y agoThe building we moved out of started doing referrals again, about 15% (according to a person I talked to at the leasing office) of their apartments are currently empty and they are still hiking prices, this isn't supply & demand, this is price systematic price gauging.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoAnecdotes are fun, and I’m sure many landlords are doing this, but the data does not generally show it. Nyc is sitting at 4% vacancy, only 1% above all time lows.
- yterdy 4y agoThat's an anecdote (regarding a single market that's known to be an outlier). Meanwhile, my experience squares with GP's. Rents don't have to follow S+D because downturn concessions can be covered by "specials" that effectively lower out-of-pocket costs for renters temporarily while keeping the market rate the same. Essentially, all discounts that would have been reflected in a lower market rate in the past are now internalized on a property manager's balance sheet.
- StrictDabbler 4y agoIt's not supply and demand, though, because the increases are well beyond vacancy pressures. I currently live in a large luxury apartment complex in a cosmopolitan city with a moderately high vacancy rate. I'm about to move out because of a large rent increase. Easily half the units in my complex are empty. Any reasonable person would look at that and say "gee, we need to bring prices down so that we have higher occupancy. Every month that a unit stands empty we're losing a whole month's rent." Instead they use RealPage. It's obvious when a complex does this because the prices change day by day and negotiation is impossible. All the other apartment complexes in this city are using the same software. Even if RealPage isn't a collusive conspiracy any error in their pricing algorithm affects the entire city. Rent on private houses are not set by RealPage so you can rent a large house here for what an apartment costs. Apartments are uniformly priced well above the "real" market price set by supply and demand. The entire city's vacancy slice is concentrated in the apartment buildings. In order to rent apartments at above market prices the apartments here have gotten slack about income verification and background checks. The only people who want to rent an apartment for well above a mortgage payment are small-time drug-dealers who have enough income to pay but not enough clean income to get a mortgage. RealPage is a market-distorting force. Inherently. In order to not distort the market they'd have to always evaluate supply and demand correctly.