4 ms·
I suspect it's a prerequisite, though perhaps not the only one. I also suspect that political stability is more likely to favour China than the USA over the ne
by ben_w 4y ago
I suspect it's a prerequisite, though perhaps not the only one.
I also suspect that political stability is more likely to favour China than the USA over the next few decades — it is very human for success to be followed by the assumption of indefatigability and that to be followed by fighting over who leads the nation, rather than continuing to focus on what actually made a nation dominant and how to keep it that way. The UK lost its literal empire that way; the Soviet Union took 50 years to go from agrarian to space, but by the end they had become at least as out of touch with their own people as the last Tsar had been; I think the US may lose its metaphorical empire similarly to the UK's actual empire, though the group deciding to call itself "The Tea Party" at least implies the possibility of it failing, with analogy to the USSR, in the same way it was formed.
- tcbawo 4y agoThe US may have backslid a bit, but it still leads the world in property ownership rights and fairness of the legal system. When a foreign corporation takes a domestic corporation to court, which jurisdiction will they get the fairest shake? What happens to billionaires when they speak critically of the Chinese government? Despite claims to the contrary, freedom of speech and rights of the property ownership are still vigilantly protected in the US.
- ben_w 4y agoCertainly; this is a hypothetical about a future where both China improves and the USA continues downhill. But even then, don't image a static world, imagine the difference (on the world stage, not in absolute terms) between the UK in 1922 and 1950, and assume the USA might fall proportionally as far by 2050. Or the growth of the Soviet Union in the same period, and apply that to China by 2050.
- KptMarchewa 4y ago>the Soviet Union took 50 years to go from agrarian to space That's a naive view of russia. Up to this day, one of the main tasks of russian army - as previously soviet - is potato harvest.
- ben_w 4y agoI can certainly believe they're like that today, given how inept they obviously are in every aspect of the Ukraine war. So much so, I will take that at face value without even bothering to google it even though it would've seemed like a surprising and unbelievable claim this time last year. That doesn't mean they didn't go to space, nor does it mean they didn't industrialise, nor does it mean they weren't a significant word power and viable threat to the USA during the Cold War.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoAgreed. It's also important to look at context of all of those achievements. For example, industrialization was greatly driven by foreign engineers and companies. Like, one of the most important figures in pre-WW2 industrialization. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_Kahn_(architect) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_Kahn_(architect) That continued after WW2. Russia was dependant on western trucks, a lot of which they gained via Land-Lease. So, they literally bought truck factory from the western companies - Kamaz - that they obviously branded as their great achievement. Production: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVI8MeOWAAEBhMB?format=jpg&name=large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVI8MeOWAAEBhMB?format=jpg&name=... Receipts: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVI8lAGWUAA37eD?format=jpg&name=large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVI8lAGWUAA37eD?format=jpg&name=... https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVI8l9eXwAEvMKM?format=jpg&name=large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FVI8l9eXwAEvMKM?format=jpg&name=...
- nivenkos 4y agoThis was the same for every industrialising country save Great Britain and a handful of others though.
- trasz2 4y ago
- nirimda 4y agoThe UK lost its literal empire because of the costs of two wars that devastated the continent - not domestic politics. On the other hand, the PRC is turning back on itself. It has been unable to produce a successor to Xi - making it very hard to change direction. Under Xi, it has actively cultivated hostility against itself and only manages to exercise influence others through force. It also has much less stable demographics. It is not reasonable to expect China to collapse and it would be fearful if they did, but they are likely to have a much less stable period ahead as they come to terms with their situation. As for the US, they're not alone in this but they are now in a situation where younger voters with a longer time horizon are able to win majorities against older voters with shorter time horizons. This means they're entering into a period of creativity. It is not clear what the outcome will be. But it is clear that we cannot take for granted that pursuit of an unreformed ideology will distract them from the compromise and teamwork that brought them to strength. In both cases, I think you're extrapolating from recent politics. But both countries are in different turns of the demographic wheel, and have different ways of dealing with that. Democracy also tends to make turmoil more obvious to external observers, so it's easy to accidentally compare apples to oranges when you're looking at a democracy and an autocracy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ben_w 4y ago> The UK lost its literal empire because of the costs of two wars that devastated the continent - not domestic politics. That’s the story the British like to tell themselves. I don’t think it fits the counterexample that Germany was able to rebuild itself enough after the first to be a world-scale threat by the second (and might have won the second in the alternative timeline where they had not been so anti-communist to attempt to conquer the USSR before the UK, and possibly also in the hypothetical alternative timeline if they had not been anti-Semitic — even before all the horrors of Holocaust became known, they were bad enough to make a significant number of Jewish scientists run away, in particular the ones went to the USA and helped with the Manhattan Project); and again after WW2 and being divided by the Allies, that Germany went from having their industrial base punitively dismantled in 1949 to The Times referring to the its reconstruction as a Wirtschaftswunder by 1959. (Yes I do know they got help, but it’s important to also know why the UK didn’t get that help, and I think part of that is the USA while part is internal domestic UK politics). It also doesn’t fit that the observation that empire, which was worldwide, had been bringing riches to the UK before the war. One thing that might have changed the cost/benefit ratios was all the locals finally getting their hands on sufficient firearms to make it expensive to suppress independence movements. Given what else the British government was busy doing with local industrial policy at that point, and the honours granted to those directly involved in war crimes during the Mau Mau uprising, I don’t think they were that self-aware. (Could also be that the USA was putting pressure on the old powers to drop their imperialism, but I don’t feel confident about the dynamic there given British cultural attitudes to the USA vary from it being “one of us, even if they don’t realise it” (no, I don’t get it either, but I’ve seen it) to “if they say jump, we ask how high”). It also doesn’t fit that the Commonwealth’s GDP is now about $11 trillion, about 3 times the UK itself; although I would regard the end of Imperialism as a morally good thing and correct all by itself, I don’t think “money” is a reasonable justification for giving up on that potential. Morally, sure. Politically, it is “gave up an empire to gain a continent… hang on, why isn’t the continent doing what we say? That must mean they are dictating to us!”