5 ms·
I'm only at the level of guessing for topics like this, but my guess is that a chain reaction is more likely to see a switch from USD to Renminbi than a switch
by ben_w 4y ago
I'm only at the level of guessing for topics like this, but my guess is that a chain reaction is more likely to see a switch from USD to Renminbi than a switch to gold (or Euros).
China because of the potential assuming similar GDP/capita as the current USA.
Not soon because I expect as a prerequisite for change being the new winner's GDP to be dominant rather than just joint top 3 in a ranking system that changes their ordering depending on what you value most.
Not gold because the justifications given for why we all stopped using the gold standard in the fist place, still seem to apply.
- tcbawo 4y agoDo you think GDP is the critical factor for determining a global reserve currency? IMO, respect for property ownership rights, legal/judicial recourse, ubiquity of US banks, and political stability are large contributing factors that few other countries can compete with. China has a pretty checkered past regarding ownership rights for citizens who are critical of its leadership.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 988747 4y agoProperty rights and such are secondary. The primary issue is: who has the power? Right now the answer to that question is "US", but since China is catching up on GDP, and, unlike US, actually manufactures things. If China decides that they want payments for all the goods that they export to be in RMB then there's nothing the rest of the world can do about it, except stop all the imports from China (which would take decades, because they have to learn to manufacture all those goods themselves). Once most of your imports come from China instead of the US it does make sense to use Chinese currency as the reserve currency, since you are going to need a lot of RMB to pay for your imports anyway.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoSaudi Arabia (to pick a major oil exporter) imports about 20% of its goods from China. But it also imports vastly more from regional partners and the US and Europe, not to mention that it depends on the US to secure all of its oil exports to China across thousands of miles of vulnerable ocean routes.
- ethbr0 4y agoChina can't tank imports until they finish pivoting to their own internal, consumptive middle class. And probably not even then. The plan the international community hoped for is actually somewhat working, the timeline for China's giant population to metabolize it was just wrong. Large Chinese middle class = power = political risk to disrupting the economy = incentive not to rock the international trade boat's status quo. The CCP is already seeing with the anger over zero-COVID that {middle class life} >> {good of the Party} for most of the population. Unfortunately, China probably also learned from the USSR that the entire charade only collapses when you blink and refrain from using the military to crush civilian dissent. Which doesn't bode well for Chinese citizens...
- FpUser 4y ago>"Unfortunately, China probably also learned from the USSR that the entire charade only collapses when you blink and refrain from using the military to crush civilian dissent." Baloney. USSR did not crush because of "civilian dissent". All the changes were driven from the top.
- ethbr0 4y agoThe Berlin Wall fell because the East German authorities and the USSR declined to shoot civilians. And the fact that order wasn't given was mostly due to bureaucratic ineptitude and delay, rather than intent. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_the_Berlin_Wall#Crowding_of_the_border https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_the_Berlin_Wall#Crow... It could have easily been Hungary 1956, Czechoslovakia 1968, Georgia 1989 instead. Progress trends towards freedom, but it can walk over a lot of corpses on its way there. :(
- FpUser 4y agoBerlin Wall did not cause the collapse of the USSR, it was one of the results of generally declining empire and change of it policies that again came from the top. Gorby and Reagan had decided to be "friends"
- ben_w 4y agoI suspect it's a prerequisite, though perhaps not the only one. I also suspect that political stability is more likely to favour China than the USA over the next few decades — it is very human for success to be followed by the assumption of indefatigability and that to be followed by fighting over who leads the nation, rather than continuing to focus on what actually made a nation dominant and how to keep it that way. The UK lost its literal empire that way; the Soviet Union took 50 years to go from agrarian to space, but by the end they had become at least as out of touch with their own people as the last Tsar had been; I think the US may lose its metaphorical empire similarly to the UK's actual empire, though the group deciding to call itself "The Tea Party" at least implies the possibility of it failing, with analogy to the USSR, in the same way it was formed.
- tcbawo 4y agoThe US may have backslid a bit, but it still leads the world in property ownership rights and fairness of the legal system. When a foreign corporation takes a domestic corporation to court, which jurisdiction will they get the fairest shake? What happens to billionaires when they speak critically of the Chinese government? Despite claims to the contrary, freedom of speech and rights of the property ownership are still vigilantly protected in the US.
- ben_w 4y agoCertainly; this is a hypothetical about a future where both China improves and the USA continues downhill. But even then, don't image a static world, imagine the difference (on the world stage, not in absolute terms) between the UK in 1922 and 1950, and assume the USA might fall proportionally as far by 2050. Or the growth of the Soviet Union in the same period, and apply that to China by 2050.
- KptMarchewa 4y ago>the Soviet Union took 50 years to go from agrarian to space That's a naive view of russia. Up to this day, one of the main tasks of russian army - as previously soviet - is potato harvest.
- ethbr0 4y agoChina might be able to force a switch to the Renminbi simply by virtue of their GDP. First as a medium of exchange (which they're doing), then as a reserve currency. But having people willingly adopt it? If people are unsatisfied with the USD in specific ways, how would those specific ways be better using the RMB? It'd be pretty shortsighted to complain about US financial manipulation or use of currency to further political goals... and then jump in mainland China's pool!
- matthewdgreen 4y agoWouldn’t a switch to Renminbi as a global reserve currency be fundamentally incompatible with China’s currency control regime? This has always been the explanation I’ve been given for why such a switchover is improbable.
- ben_w 4y agoCould be; I don't even understand British economic policies, despite my nationality, Chinese economic policies are completely outside my domain of knowledge.
- Tarq0n 4y agoThere's also a lot less in circulation. The US Dollar has by far the largest volume out of any currency, which helps other central banks manage their holdings. This is something that holds back for instance the euro to be used for reserve banking.