3 ms·
Breech of contract isn’t the same thing as fraud. A full time employment contract doesn’t preclude other things which take up significant time such as voluntee
by Retric 4y ago
Breech of contract isn’t the same thing as fraud.
A full time employment contract doesn’t preclude other things which take up significant time such as volunteering, or parenthood. Companies want exclusivity to increase their bargaining position, but they simply fire most of these people rather than sue for damages because it’s difficult to prove any harm.
- mytherin 4y agoIf you are charging two companies for 40 hours per week of work, while only working 20 hours per week for each of them, then that is fraud by any reasonable definition of the word.
- ok_dad 4y agoSo I guess all those companies paying for 40 hours and getting 50 or 60 should be charged charged with fraud?
- mytherin 4y agoIf your employer expects you to work 50 or 60 hours while only paying you for 40 hours then that is indeed also illegal.
- w4ffl35 4y agoI take it you've never had a salary pay job in America. One of my recent jobs had me working 100 hours per week for $130k (base salary). Every job I've ever had expected overtime without extra pay. One job had me working through every holiday without bonus. I've had some shitty jobs, but it wasn't illegal for them to demand this out of me.
- Terretta 4y agoFor anyone working crazy hours and getting paid salary while having zero sense of control, it's worth checking if you're misclassified as exempt: https://www.thebalancemoney.com/exempt-and-a-non-exempt-employee-2061988 https://www.thebalancemoney.com/exempt-and-a-non-exempt-empl... If you work with computers, or are above 100k and any part of the job is executive, administrative, or professional, you're probably not, though.
- w4ffl35 4y agohave looked into this for myself and i'm definitely exempt from being paid overtime. i now take these unreasonable demands as a sign that the employer wants me to quit.
- chrisbaker98 4y agoMy contract says that I'm expected to work Monday to Friday 9am to 6pm with a one hour lunch break (so 40 hours) but it also has some vague, ambiguous language about "occasionally" working "additional hours" as business demands it. So they can make me work 50-60 hours in one week and it wouldn't breach my contract.
- fbdab103 4y agoAre we suddenly counting people who show up and only give a partial effort? I am not sure you are prepared for how deep this rabbit hole goes.
- Retric 4y agoThat assumes you are working 20 hours at each, plenty of people work 80+ hour weeks.
- 314 4y agofraud: wrongful or criminal deception intended to result in financial or personal gain. If you sign a full-time contract and claim that you are only working a single job, while holding down multiple jobs then you are lying for financial gain.
- reillyse 4y agoBut it’s such a vague statement that it could actually apply to lots of things. Like say advertisements. Say dating. Say pretty much everything that happens all the time. The definition of fraud you use is overly general.
- sokoloff 4y agoPerhaps you could provide another reasonable definition of fraud to support an argument that this behavior is not fraudulent?
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoI'm pretty sure a lot of what is described would fall under fraud in most jurisdictions if these things are in either of the contracts, as they tend to be in mine. 1. Length of hours worked per week and work start and end - if you are supposed to be working in times between 8 and 17 with a total of 37.5 hours worked per week if you do a couple 1 hour meetings between 9 and 16 for employer B every day then you have defrauded employer A because it would be impossible for you to make that 37.5 hours between 8 and 17 they are paying you for. You have deceived the company that you are working for them and receiving compensation while working for another company. It's pretty open and shut in legal terms and no but what about lying to a date pontificating is going to change that. 2. Do the contracts with companies have clauses about how they own everything you product technology wise while working for them? on edit: changed time usage from American to Military Time / European in one instance so all usages were aligned.
- MetaKiller4000 4y agoI don’t care what the contract says. If all of my employers are satisfied with my work, I don’t feel any remorse. Employment contracts are part of the game. Overemployment is part of the metagame :-)
- chrisbaker98 4y agoWell now we're just arguing semantics, but here's Dictionary.com's definition of fraud: "deceit, trickery, sharp practice, or breach of confidence, perpetrated for profit or to gain some unfair or dishonest advantage." I don't know if getting a second job wouldn't be fraud in a strict legalistic sense, but it definitely meets the above definition. Anyway, if you wanna do it, go ahead. I'm not going to risk it myself, but I've worked at plenty of companies which were badly-enough run that I can imagine getting away with this kind of behaviour. I've also worked for employers who treated me like garbage, so I can understand why some people might have no objection to treating their employer like garbage.
- roxgib 4y agoWhen someone is saying 'fraud', I think most people are talking specifically about a criminal offence of some kind.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]