4 ms·
"Enforcement powers, while conceptually broader with respect to non-SEC regulated entities, are still circumscribed by statute, federal judicial review, congres
by Animats 4y ago
"Enforcement powers, while conceptually broader with respect to non-SEC
regulated entities, are still circumscribed by statute, federal judicial review, congressional
oversight and the Commission’s own policies and procedures for initiating and conducting
inquiries and investigations."
Now that's being squishy-soft on crime. That's the point to make when those members of Congress come up for re-election. They're soft on crime.
The basic law the SEC enforces, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, is pretty clear on what's a security. The Supreme Court has clarified that. Investment of money, expectation of profit, common enterprise - it's a security. That's called the Howey Test. It's also been established that what you call it or how it works doesn't matter. There have been, over the years, many imaginative schemes cooked up to get around this. The Howey case involved tradeable orange grove harvesting rights in Florida. That was held to be a security.
The crypto crowd has been yammering for years "but this is different". Well, it's not.
The scams around crypto are classic. It's usually insiders stealing the money. The crashes are also classic. It's someone being over-leveraged when something goes down.
This is not financial innovation.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y ago>”The crypto crowd has been yammering for years "but this is different". Well, it's not.” In what way? Some cryptocurrencies have been declared securities, while many have not. Those such as Bitcoin and Ethereum have been around for long enough that if they were going to be ruled as securities via Howey, that would have surely been done by now.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> that would have surely been done by now We are getting damn close to that being done through statute in the U.S.
- Animats 4y agoThat was done years ago. The SEC cracked down on initial coin offerings back in 2018. They're still working down the backlog.[1] The "cyber" enforcement staff was doubled a few months back to catch up. The SEC does not consider Bitcoin to be a security because there's no "common enterprise". It's distributed more like a mined commodity. Miners are competitors. But where there's an issuer, or "minting", or "pre-mining", or anything like that, you can buy it, and it's expected to go up, it's clearly a security. Etherium is in an interesting position with the shift to proof of stake. That may have made it a security, because it's now controlled by voting owners, just like a stock. So now there's a "common enterprise", unlike in the "mining" phase. The big question now is exchange regulation. Are Bitcoin exchanges and brokers going to have to register with the SEC, pay for and be covered by SIPC insurance, and be regulated by FINRA? After FTX, that's probably coming. FTX acted like a retail broker, after all. Nobody runs Super Bowl ads or buys stadium naming rights for something sold only to institutional clients. The law in this area looks at the economic realities, not the form. If it looks like a security, is marketed like a security, and is bought and sold for the same reasons as securities, it's a security. Doesn't matter what you call it. [1] https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/cybersecurity-enforcement-actions https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/cybersecurity-enforcement-acti...