6 ms·
My impression is that at this point 'puppet' is far too strong a term. North Korea still relies on the PRC's tolerance and patronage, and the PRC doesn't prefe
by gojomo 15y ago
My impression is that at this point 'puppet' is far too strong a term.
North Korea still relies on the PRC's tolerance and patronage, and the PRC doesn't prefer any outcome that boosts the influence of the US and South Korea. But the PRC's influence and patience with North Korea are limited. Some of the Wikileaks cables indicate China has begun backing away from the regime:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/nov/29/wikileaks-cables-china-reunified-korea http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/nov/29/wikileaks-cables...
- Duff 15y agoNorth Korea is a vassal state of the PRC, and exists because it is politically advantageous to China for them to do so. Until recently, China hasn't liked to take a direct approach to many aspects of international affairs. So they influence countries like North Korea, Pakistan, and Iran as tools to achieve their political aims. They aren't whole-hearted supporters of all aspects of the North Korean regime, frankly, I'd say that they don't really care about what happens in North Korea, as long as they are achieving their foreign policy goals.
- jbooth 15y agoChina's interests (and hence, position) are "don't fuck around and create trouble for us". A collapsed NK state creates more trouble for China in the form of refugees than a still-functioning one, so we see enough aid for them to keep functioning. An occasional diplomatic poke in the eye to the US helps China too, but that's a want, not a need. Don't confuse the rhetoric with the reality.
- nknight 15y agoYeah, in the event of actual war, there's no way they intervene as long as the North Koreans are the aggressors -- they know North Korea will lose on its own, and they don't want to get into a fight with the US. South Korea's one of their major trading partners now, too. I think they let a US/SK operation clean up while issuing various diplomatic missives decrying the violence, then wrangle a treaty barring major military installations or exercises in northern areas of, and establishing free trade with, the reunified Korea.
- gwern 15y agoIt's worth noting that they did intervene the last time the North Koreans were the aggressors, that is, the Korean War.
- jbooth 15y agoIt's also worth noting that 1950 China has very little in common with 2011 China.
- gwern 15y agoIndeed, but it also has some factors in common through different pathways - I grow nervous when I read of the ultranationalist riots permitted by the Party, because it seems like the kind of thing that would itself to the leaders deciding to enter 'a short, victorious war'. (Defending the Middle Kingdom, defending the Revolution; rather similar.)
- jbooth 15y agoEntirely different, see my comment above about Deng Xiaopeng's ascendance in the late 1970s and the quite severe repercussions for the perpetrators of the Cultural Revolution. There's no linkage between the revolution and nationalism anymore. "A cat that catches mice is a good cat, whether it's white or black". Nationalist pride, sure, that's been a constant through any cohesive nation's history. Koreans aren't Chinese, though, and the leaders of China are too smart to look for a "short, victorious war" on the Korean peninsula..
- gwern 15y agoI didn't say nationalism and the Revolution were the same thing, I said they could play the same role.
- afterburner 15y agoPartly because MacArthur was looking (and talking) like he was going to press on into China as he stormed up the peninsula after the landings at Incheon.