2 ms·
> It's not that the algo is any worse than human recommendations, it's just that it's an average of all humans likes, which will never fit your exact personal u
by majormajor 4y ago
> It's not that the algo is any worse than human recommendations, it's just that it's an average of all humans likes, which will never fit your exact personal unique preferences because they aren't you.
Isn't that the definition of "worse"? "Never able to be tailored to your unique preferences" when a human could take that feedback in a single sentence and adjust? It's like the old "everyone wants to remake Excel since they realize 80% of users only use 20% of it... without realizing it's always a different 20%" saw...
I believe that you certainly could figure out a smarter approach, with enough careful thought, domain knowledge, and effort but... I haven't used any services that do it. Surface level similarities seems to be all you get, and I constantly get recommendations that a human would've stopped giving me years ago.
Maybe the domain of expert-level statisticians and experts-at-musical-knowledge-of-many-genres just don't overlap that much? It's hard to imagine you could do it truly well without content-level processing, not just user histories and connection graphs.
Just because no streaming service could afford a human to be an expert on every single user doesn't mean that the cheaper, more scalable algorithm isn't worse.
- emodendroket 4y agoI mean, maybe it's not worse though. Maybe others would find what the other guy wants too narrow. There's a tension between only playing stuff you are 100% going to like and actually introducing you to stuff you haven't listened to.
- majormajor 4y ago> Maybe others would find what the other guy wants too narrow. That's exactly what makes it worse, though. They currently have to choose more globally, it's not that personalized. in the human-curated world others would get different things. I know they don't like Slipknot, I know you do, I give you each different recommendations. Spotify's code hasn't shown the ability to learn "me" vs it's view of what the "average me" would like.
- emodendroket 4y agoCan't you refine your results by telling it to stop recommending an artist?