4 ms·
> Primary funding for the website will be provided by website owners and copyright holders, So there's now a tax to run a website. And we centralize control o
by Natsu 15y ago
> Primary funding for the website will be provided by website owners and copyright holders,
So there's now a tax to run a website. And we centralize control over the whole internet via DMCA.org? We're climbing a steep hill here and we've barely started. Also, you realize that sites can be served via compromised computers... right? Who answers for those? Not a big problem, you say? Well, aside from the botnets and such already out there that you apparently don't know about. And we're creating new incentives to create such things, too....
> Each website has a DMCA score based on complaints, response times and repeat violations, and websites with "mass infringement" status may be blocked
I assume you have the Pirate Bay in mind, but pretty much any popular user-generated site drowns in complaints already. And many of them already have tools that big rightsholders can use. So do we shut down YouTube? Viacom tried to.
Finally, there's all this stuff about "blocking." You're assuming that you can make a block that works. Problem is, you can't. If there's one source in all the world, it's enough for everyone. You can't block 99% of the world, because that last 1% will share copies with the rest. There are no filters on sneakernet. You vastly underestimate the bandwidth of a truck full of DVDs. The government couldn't stop the spread of thousands of classified cables with the military at their disposal. China can't stop dissidents from getting through the Great Firewall. I've watched, for basically my entire life, as people came up with the same ideas, then hit the same failures. For every wall you put up, someone will create a ladder or a tunnel. Even Sisyphus didn't have it that bad.
You can't really make piracy significantly harder, but you can make buying things easier. Look at iTunes: I doubt there's a single thing on there that can't be found somewhere online for free. Yet they're a huge success because it's fast, easy & convenient. Make it easy to buy, easy to use, fun to experience. The pirates can't copy you, and successful performers make use of that, too.
But get your fans caught in the crossfire when you're trying to make things harder to pirate and they'll abandon you for an artist who treats them well. They're not pirates: they can, will and have bought from people who treated them well. But if you screw them when going after pirates, well, there's a lot of other music out there to buy and they don't need yours. Reminding potential customers that they don't need to listen to your music is not great for conversion, incidentally. But don't take my word for it, run an A/B test and see.
That said, you're absolutely right that things need fixing. But a far more realistic approach would be to fix copyright itself. William Patry (a famous lawyer & scholar of all things copyright) has a new book with some interesting thoughts on that:
http://books.google.com/books/about/How_to_Fix_Copyright.html?id=8-4catWPy84C http://books.google.com/books/about/How_to_Fix_Copyright.htm...
Like he says, "the proxy battle for control of technology and markets through copyright laws must stop."