4 ms·
A serious problem with this is scaling of operating costs. A 5 MWe reactor, operating at about 90% capacity factor and selling power at wholesale prices (maybe
by pfdietz 4y ago
A serious problem with this is scaling of operating costs.
A 5 MWe reactor, operating at about 90% capacity factor and selling power at wholesale prices (maybe $0.03/kWh) will earn $1.2M/year. You need at least four employees to operate it (3 shifts, with a spare), and probably many more.
- mjlawson 4y agoI'm no expert here, but I wonder about the economics around the 13MW of heat that it outputs. There are certainly applications around the world where that could be hugely beneficial. Take Reykjavik[1] for example. How much are they paying for their system now on a yearly basis? How would they like an extra 5MW of energy along with it? [1] https://vahterus.com/resources/cases/10-mw-heat-pump-system-to-boost-a-volcanic-district-heating-solution-in-reykjavik/ https://vahterus.com/resources/cases/10-mw-heat-pump-system-...
- zeristor 4y agoI’d guess they have enough geothermal power for the time being.
- jonstewart 4y agoTFA even mentions Alaska and Saskatchewan...
- danans 4y ago> I wonder about the economics around the 13MW of heat that it outputs. I'll take a stab, if only to start a discussion: 13MW is about 450MBTU/hr. Natural gas is about $7/MBTU. Assuming 80% efficiency of gas to heat conversion, you would need 562MBTU/hr, or a cost of about $80/hour. If the heat from this nuclear device is sold at the same price per unit heat, it will make $80*8760=$700800/year. If read correctly, the reactor can make either 5MW of electricity or 13MW of heat, but not both, so it wouldn't make a lot of sense to sell the 13MW of heat. At best sell some of the waste 8MW to make a few extra marginal bucks.
- Panzer04 4y agoI imagine the heat could be captured and you do both, but you'd need a system to do that, which is probably more expensive.
- nine_k 4y agoNatural gas is only $7 / BTU if you are near an LNG terminal. "Remote areas" usually are not. Think about a military base, a relief effort camp after a major natural disaster, of a mining site in the middle of Canada or Siberia, stuff like that.
- Someone 4y agoThat Reykjavik doesn’t use energy to make heat; it uses it to pump it from A to B. In addition, I guess the heat it pumps is geothermal (FTA: The new setup is expected to provide over 40 GWh/year of free ocean heat.) A benefit of using this kind of reactor might be that the source of heat could be moved closer to where it’s needed, If so, but I don’t expect that to offset the advantage of the current heat source giving you heat for free.
- Accujack 4y agoFrom the article, they're planning on the reactors being unmanned (but monitored). So, no employees watching it.
- pfdietz 4y agoThat's going to require changes in licensing in the US. I don't think even remotely operated reactors are legal in the US.
- ipdashc 4y agoHow are they planning to handle security? The rest of the thread mentions they intend to use these in very remote regions (northern Canada and such). While that makes a lot of sense practically, doesn't it make security kind of tricky? I get that they'd be carefully remotely monitored, but it seems like a realistic possibility that a team of people could break in (the renders show these in shipping containers surrounded by a simple double layer of barbed wire fencing), steal the radioactive material, and escape before security arrives. I get that we store actual nuclear bombs in unmanned remote sites (missile silos), but those are operated by the literal military and secure underground. These would realistically be operated by private companies, and are just shipping containers sitting on the surface.
- mike_hearn 4y agoThey don't have to be on the surface. Infrastructure is often buried underground even for non-security related reasons.
- zizee 4y agoSomeone wrote in another thread: > It uses TRISO fuel, which are fissionable materials enclosed in a carbon and ceramic shell that's extremely tough and can handle far higher temperatures than are present in a reactor without melting. Each grain of fuel is about the size of a poppy seed, with the majority of the seed being the ceramic shell. It's not a dense fuel. This stops issues of radioactive material leaching into groundwater, and also makes it quite difficult to use the fuel for nefarious purposes (like a dirty bomb). Someone would need to separate the fuel from the shell, not a trivial thing to do. All this to say that it's not super attractive for terrorist types. Also, remember that whilst they talk about using them in remote areas, it's mostly about being "remote to other infrastructure", not "remote from all people". These things will be installed in small regional towns / mine sites etc. Places where a town sized number of people will be. So it's not like it will be hours away from any first responder. Finally, these can be secured pretty well physically. They won't be easy to move, or cut into, or siphon out the material, at least not in a smash-and-grab type scenario. https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/triso-particles-most-robust-nuclear-fuel-earth https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/triso-particles-most-robu... edit: I wouldn't say they are risk free, just not as big a risk as it first sounds locating a nuclear reactor out in the middle of nowhere :-) edit2: I'm by no means an expert, but I really liked this video on the topic on the benefits of Small Modular Reactors (SMRs). I really love the concept, especially their mass produced, regularly rotated/retired nature: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TYnqJ4VnRM8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TYnqJ4VnRM8
- Schroedingersat 4y agoI assume the intent is to have a bunch of them replacing the boilers in a large coal plant. Capex and security wise it seems pretty good, and I'd expect capacity factors going on 100% for the heat generating part as it's incredibly simple and you just swap the whole thing once a decade. But it's nuclear so there's always a scam if you look at the other hand instead of where they're directing your attention. The card in the other hand today is it uses TRISO fuel. This produces >10x the high level waste which can't be reprocessed. It uses twice as much uranium, triple the enrichment (at levels not possible with most current enrichment facilities). And it is fabricated using a process that is estimated to cost anywhere from $40 to $600 per MWh. More than likely it also needs a much higher quantity of hafnium or iridium or silver for control rods as well, and odds are you can't make the heat pipes out of non-exotic materials.
- pfdietz 4y agoIt uses reflectors instead of control rods.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoMade of? If you say beryllium there's another non-starter. Graphite would be workable though.
- pfdietz 4y agoThey don't say.