5 ms·
Volkswagen says all brands have halted paid activities on Twitter
- carl_dr 4y agoCan anyone why ELI5 please? The discussion on Twitter isn’t very … analytical.
- dragontamer 4y agoTwitter's Advertisement teams have been decimated, possibly to the point of non-existence. I've seen online advertisers complaining that their emails / issues are not getting any responses in the past two weeks, despite concerns about advertisements + brands being shown next to pornographic material (which is the fastest growing section of Twitter this year, even before Musk). While porn has been on the rise on Twitter, the uptick of branding next to pornography is a recent issue. I'm guessing that a lot of those services Mr. Musk turned off in the past two weeks were related to brand-protection that these advertisers cared about. Its no secret that lots of social media sites have pornography sections. But what brands want is assurances that their advertisements are isolated away from those corners, especially for brands like Kellogg's, Mars, and other brands that want to build a strong brand with children. ------ I'm not sure what Volkswagen is worried about: it could be that Volkswagen just doesn't want to give money to Twitter when its obviously going to just be funneled to Elon Musk / TSLA eventually. Still, the loss of Volkswagen is yet another papercut in this slew of advertisers that have left Twitter.
- carl_dr 4y agoThanks, that helps.
- tdeck 4y agoAlso worth nothing that about 4/5 of the content moderation team were laid off, so anything that involves a human in the loop will be compromised (more ML processes than you might think have a manual review phase).
- coffeefirst 4y agoFurthermore, Brand Safety is a standard requirement for ALL serious advertisers. They have lists of topics and keywords to avoid, and if you can’t ensure that (or at least send a rep to apologize and fix it when the prevention mechanism is imperfect), they won’t run with you. This isn’t new or complicated. The only person who doesn’t seem to understand it is Musk.
- themoonisachees 4y agoMusk hasn't needed to understand that, ever. Every one of the companies he doesn't do actual work for he could just spare a small loan of a billion emerald dollars and be fine. He could do the same with twitter but i think he wants it to fail because he never intended on actually going through with the purchase and just wanted to pump and dump the stock.
- squokko 4y agoYes, also anyone spending money with a company and can afford not to, expects to be treated like a king. They expect a real person to pick up the phone and kiss their ass.
- dendrite9 4y agoThe pornographic content became noticeable for me at some point in the summer. It was strange, almost all in Spanish and with no clear connection to the 4ish subjects I followed on twitter with that account. That account ran its course otherwise I'd go back on and check if that is still happening. In general I wonder what levers get connected to ad targeting. Several years ago I started to get substantial personalized ads in Spanish somewhere else (maybe youtube?) after a year it went back to English. I also had an account that had a 50-50 mix of German and English for a while.
- squokko 4y ago1) Why enrich the CEO of a competitor car company? 2) Why do business with a company whose CEO makes public posts like a 9-year-old edgelord? 3) Why even bother? Twitter can't have been more than 1% of VW's ad budget.
- bergenty 4y agoIt’s a toxic (racist/sexist) place now I assume.
- ratsmack 4y agoI can assure you, it's exactly like it was before, the rules of engagement weren't changed. The only thing I notice is that there is more activity now.
- zamalek 4y agoAmoungst other things, Twitter is now far less willing to deal with hate speech. Brands hardly want to be seen near that type of content.
- 0898 4y agoIt’s fascinating that Volkswagen is presenting itself as a paragon of virtue, having spent years actively deceiving regulators over its cars’ emissions.
- squokko 4y agoI don't think this is virtue signaling - it's just walking away from a business partner that is in a period of extreme chaos.
- iceburgcrm 4y agoIt's both and a bit of free brand advertising. I fear I won't be able to tell my kids how Volkswagen is changing the world without these brand ads
- danudey 4y agoCan you elaborate? I'm not seeing VW present itself as a paragon of virtue, just not advertising on a platform which no longer has teams capable of managing advertising (e.g. ensuring that you're not showing your advertising next to pornography or white nationalism). No one is playing the virtue card here, it's just practical business.
- xhkkffbf 4y agoIn the past, VW celebrated the diesel engines in their cars because of the higher mileage. The emissions, though, weren't so great and they were caught deceiving the regulators who try to stop air pollution. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal I think these events are pretty separate and independent.
- CodeWriter23 4y agoLooks like the regulators failed. Where are the clean diesels now? Gone because the NOx limits created by the aforementioned regulators set the bar too high. Instead we’re now only making ICEs that are gasoline-powered for passenger vehicles. Burning 1.5-2x the carbon for the same distance as clean diesel. IMO VW and the others who have since quietly withdrawn their clean diesels from the market hoped regulators would pull their heads out of their asses and get real on NOx limits. Cars like the TDI line were about 1/16th the NOx emission of a standard diesel-powered box truck.
- theCrowing 4y agoAs an automotive company I would also divert my ad spending from plattforms that are controlled by the ceo of one of my competitors...
- xhkkffbf 4y agoI think General Motors is another one very publicly making the same kind of announcement. It does seem like a competitive decision motivated by the car business.
- testbjjl 4y agoBut that’s not the reason why, chaos is, though I imagine it didn’t give them pause. We all can speculate about what comes next. My guess is Elon saying he “inherited a mess” much more “broken” than he could have imagined. I also notice bots aren’t much part of the conversation any longer.
- klyrs 4y agoHe certainly doesn't want to sue himself for fraud...
- KptMarchewa 4y agoLike Walmart not running their services on AWS.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoVolkswagen was very close to Musk in the past. https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/teslas-musk-dials-into-volkswagen-executive-conference-2021-10-16/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/teslas...
- amadeuspagel 4y agoMusk and Diess were close, but as far as I know there was never any cooperation between the companies.
- 4y ago
- xqcgrek2 4y agoMarket distortions tend to fix themselves over time. Either Twitter's ad rates drop so supply and demand get back into balance, or someone will gladly take the eyeballs VW was getting at the current rate.
- xhkkffbf 4y agoPeople are considering this possibility and investing accordingly. One guy has tracked the performance of some of these companies openly proclaiming their anti-Twitter position and claims that they've been underperforming the stock market. This means there's a chance to short them. https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/anti-twitter-advertisers-have-been-under-performing-market-months-here-your-chance-short https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/anti-twitter-advertisers-h...
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoThe guy telling you how to invest to hurt companies that "hate free speech" doesn't really seem like a reliable source of market tips.
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoStill thinking about this. This bit really struck me: > ...those companies have reportedly pulled hundreds of millions of dollars worth of advertising from the social media platform (despite Musk's insistence that "Twitter’s strong commitment to content moderation remains absolutely unchanged.") I wanna say, but you know that's a lie. You love Musk because it's a lie. The whole reason you cheer for him is that he promised to stop banning the people you like. Who are you trying to convince by claiming Twitter's moderation policy is unchanged? The left isn't fooled and the right doesn't care.
- speakfreely 4y agoThe different companies buying ads are not interchangeable. Brands, who typically have the biggest budgets, all care about brand management (where their brand is shown, what it's shown next to, before and after), which can't be done effectively now that the staff that handles these things has been gutted. There's no way to get those advertisers back without rebuilding that part of the business and there's no other type of advertiser that can step in to fill the size of that gap. If anything, the reduced quality of the performance marketers who move in to buy ads for scammy weight loss, skin care, get rich quick offers are going to drive away any big brand advertisers who are actually trying to stay on Twitter and weather the storm.
- Beaver117 4y agoIf corporations have a duty to bring profit to shareholders, I hope all these companies have done proper analysis/testing to determine if showing their ads next to porn is unprofitable. Just saying...
- ralph84 4y agoMusk’s companies are famous for spending $0 on traditional marketing and PR. It’s not surprising he doesn’t understand how to keep marketers happy now that they’re his customers.
- erk__ 4y agoWell at least that was true until recently https://www.reuters.com/technology/spacex-buys-ad-campaign-twitter-starlink-musk-says-2022-11-14/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/spacex-buys-ad-campaign-t...
- pifm_guy 4y agoAdvertisers working together like this can have a massive impact on a company... Remember when advertiser's did this to YouTube, and immediately YouTube management folded and started demonetizing anything advertisers had any objections to like LGBT content?
- tempera 4y agoThis is a win for Twitter. Why allow yourself to be a hostage to advertisers?
- rieTohgh6 4y ago90%+ of their revenue comes from ads, how could they not care about advertisers?
- tempera 4y agoYou should care, but not become a hostage to them. Advertisers will need Twitter much more than Twitter will need them, soon.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoIf I have to ban 5% of shitty accounts to reduce as much hate speech as possible and have some infrastructure to keep out trollbots whilst becoming rich I would have no problem with that. Twitter is a platform, not a government. No one has any right to speech on there other than that which the platform chooses to allow. Musk seems to value racist and bigoted speech on his platform. No one is going to pay for that and no one is going to advertise on it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- okokwhatever 4y agoWhy would VW pay for ads in a company owned by Musk? It makes no sense at all. But... I guess there will be a lot of companies in the renewable energies industry that will be very interested into be represented in twitter from now on.