4 ms·
Another loss of freedom for US citizens, permitting corporations to retain yet another freedom that has been taken away from real human beings. > the subject p
by kragen 4y ago
Another loss of freedom for US citizens, permitting corporations to retain yet another freedom that has been taken away from real human beings.
> the subject products do not
include magnet products sold and/or
distributed solely to school educators,
researchers, professionals, and/or
commercial or industrial users
exclusively for educational, research,
professional, commercial, and/or
industrial purposes.
They're specifically targeting artisan jewelers:
> Another
example of a subject magnet product is
jewelry with separable magnets, such as
jewelry-making sets
One more step towards prison-style "knives are contraband".
However, this is specifically for magnets that fit inside the CPSC's "small parts cylinder" (defined in medieval units as 2.25 "inches" long by 1.25 "inches" wide, which is 57 mm × 32 mm in modern units), which is designed to approximate what a toddler can swallow, so large strong magnets (over 32 mm diameter or 57 mm long) are not affected. You can saw large strong magnets into small strong magnets. Nickel-plating them afterwards to reduce the risk of chipping is a big pain, but not always necessary.
All this in response the death of one toddler in the US and one 8-year-old in Poland, plus 56 other hospital admissions over a three-year period.
- rrobukef 4y agoI'd like to correct your statistics: 1119 sampled emergency department treatments over 11 years and an estimated 25000 emergency room visits for the whole of the US. An estimated 20% (5000 people) were hospitalized. 94% of the visit involved things falling under this regulation. In a separate study, 46.4% of the children required procedures, of which 14.2% required surgery and 9.6% got sick ("morbidity"). They also mention at least 3 death-cases. Source: the report [https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2022-09-21/pdf/2022-20200.pdf https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2022-09-21/pdf/2022-2...]
- kragen 4y agoI appreciate the correction; 230 visits per year across the US is indeed significantly different from 19 visits per year. But this corrected statistic still paints an overall picture of an almost insignificant risk, hundreds of times smaller than being struck by lightning — more like the injury and death rates of shark attacks, falling cows, cactus spine injuries, slipping on orange peels, and fights between humans and roosters. This hardly seems like an adequate justification for extensive new restrictions on valuable experimental materials. It seems more like the EU's unreasonable new restrictions on access to borax.