3 ms·
> A large coalition of political/social activist groups agreed not to try to kill Twitter by starving us of advertising revenue if I agreed to this condition. T
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> A large coalition of political/social activist groups agreed not to try to kill Twitter by starving us of advertising revenue if I agreed to this condition. They broke the deal.
As with the Russian claims about a deal for NATO to permanently not expand in Eastern Europe, this is easy to show is unlikely to be true:
(1) In either case, these are things that would be recognized of utmost significance by all sides.
(2) In either case, the allegedly aggrieved parties (or their relevant predecessors in interests) were sophisticated actors, long used to working in an environment where durable binding agreements, particularly ones of great significance, were memorialized in writing affirmed by all parties, with copies retained by all parties, to assure that the terms are clear, fixed, and that evidence can be produced of them in the event of any public or private dispute.
(3) In neither case can the allegedly aggrieved party produce the writing memorializing the agreement, or any explanation as to why they (or their predecessor in interest) would not, as a condition for what they were giving up in the agreement, insist upon the common step of memorializing the agreement in writing,
(4) Therefore, it is highly improbable that the narrative of the aggrieved party is accurate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- somenameforme 4y agoIn the case of NATO it's even easier to show that it is true: https://www.spiegel.de/international/world/nato-s-eastward-expansion-did-the-west-break-its-promise-to-moscow-a-663315.html https://www.spiegel.de/international/world/nato-s-eastward-e... "After speaking with many of those involved and examining previously classified British and German documents in detail, SPIEGEL has concluded that there was no doubt that the West did everything it could to give the Soviets the impression that NATO membership was out of the question for countries like Poland, Hungary or Czechoslovakia."
- dragonwriter 4y agoI mean, if you fail to distinguish “giving an impression of current intention based on the current geopolitical context” with “making a binding, heritable commitment”, sure. But you’d have to be incredibly dishonest to present something that explicitly describes the former as showing the latter. Especially when the article you cite also says that the Soviets chose not to seek a binding commitment largely because they could not imagine a situation coming into existence where it would matter, given the then-current continued existence of the Warsaw Pact, and that the Western powers were disclaiming immediate intentions but in their own discussions had deferred anything longer term. So, in short, its clear that the USSR didn’t imagine the need for a long term commitment and didn’t seek one, and that the West would not have been prepared to offer one, and so no agreement incorporating such a commitment was discussed or made, verbally or otherwise.
- spaced-out 4y agoIt was out of question in the mind of those officials, at that time. NATO was expanded under later administrations.