3 ms·
They did have a disclaimer in every page that AI models hallucinate. But Lecun has been caught in the general 'facebook bad' sentiment and some human broken clo
by seydor 4y ago
They did have a disclaimer in every page that AI models hallucinate. But Lecun has been caught in the general 'facebook bad' sentiment and some human broken clocks who are constantly bashing anything DL-related.
this is just a bunch of personal vendettas imho. The model was useful
- Veen 4y agoUseful for doing what? Certainly not what LeCun and Meta originally claimed it was useful for.
- seydor 4y agoDo you know what they claimed it was doing?
- Veen 4y agoI know what LeCun originally said on Twitter and what the copy on the Galactica web page said. But to repeat my question, what is the model useful for? How can it be used to achieve something that bears any resemblance to the original claims?
- seydor 4y agoAfaik the claim was not that "it writes correct papers", but that it compiles knowledge. and to that extent it was accurate, along with the disclaimer that it hallucinates things, because it goes on tangents that are often unrelted The paper was useful for that reason: as a search engine for underresearched and speculative connections within fields, and from what i saw it does well in that. For example, when brainwashing ideas or looking for other research directions to review. In fact, we already have Perspectives papers being published in journals which are speculative in nature. This is a reasonable take on its usefulness: https://twitter.com/mad_enrico/status/1592664384031330309 https://twitter.com/mad_enrico/status/1592664384031330309 > It's still not perfect but a very interesting tool to search about new topics,
- fastball 4y agoI used it to help produce LaTeX code representing chemical structures, which normally would've taken me somewhere around 10 minutes but took me 30s instead.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoYou’re wrong but I hope LeCun/Zuck sees this bro :)
- tsimionescu 4y agoThey did not - see my other comment for an archive.org link, but it was only at the bottom of the Mission page.
- bitL 4y agoIf they manage to create a differentiable information retrieval system (i.e. a database that informs neural nets about facts) then the hallucination part might go away.
- iudqnolq 4y agoThe main criticism I saw was that that seeing disclaimer required clicking a link. I saw screenshots of the homepage implying it didn't hallucinate, and article pages without disclaimers. Were they doctored?