3 ms·
While you are right in principle, the example with the ECC memory is not really appropriate. The case with the ECC memory, which has been created by Intel when
by adrian_b 4y ago
While you are right in principle, the example with the ECC memory is not really appropriate.
The case with the ECC memory, which has been created by Intel when they have segmented the market between Pentium and Pentium Pro, is an example of a market segmentation technique where the vendor brainwashes the naive part of their customers to believe that they do not need a certain feature and that they might get cheaper products without that feature, but in fact the vendor sells the products with the disabled feature at the same price as before, to the naive customers, while using the fact that they disable the feature wanted by the experienced customers as a means of extortion to force the latter to pay much more money for the non-crippled products.
ECC is a feature that should have been mandatory by law on any computer, at least on all models where the memory is not soldered, but on modules inserted in sockets.
If there is no ECC, that guarantees that the computer will make mistakes from time to time. Even if the consequences of computer errors can have very different costs, depending on the application, nobody needs a computer that will make mistakes.
Even for someone who uses a computer only for games or for watching movies, so that a computer error should have very little importance, the lack of ECC still introduces a very small risk that, if the user is not careful to keep backup copies, some actions like copying some game assets or movies could produce corrupt files.
For someone who uses a computer creatively, the risk of computer errors can become non-negligible.
- formerly_proven 4y agoI think almost all problems with my computers so far have been bad memory or OCZ SSDs. But the performance hit you take for games and some other things is also very real and big. The very best DDR4 ECC memory on the market is DDR4-3600 CL16-19-19-39, which a) is not a good bin to start with, almost certainly with bad tertiary timings and b) costs more than twice as much as equivalent non-ECC.
- O5vYtytb 4y agoWell sure, but that's because there's little demand for fast ecc memory by the gaming crowd due to the aforementioned market segmentation. There's no substantial limitation on ddr speed due to ECC itself.
- smolder 4y agoThat's just more market segmentation. If Intel had smartly made ECC a standard feature, we'd just have high speed ECC kits with good timings aimed at enthusiasts. There's no technical limitation on ECC that stops you from running the chips fast at increased voltage.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> OCZ Wow that's a name I haven't heard in a LONG time... Is there a name for the phenomenon where you don't hear about something for years, but you don't notice until it's mentioned, and suddenly you go "Wait...what happened to them?" I'm fairly sure I had a 128 GB OCZ SSD back in the day.
- BuckRogers 4y agoI had a couple of OCZ drives. They were pretty flaky and unreliable. The Intel X25–M drives were really the first production ready consumer drives that I ever used. I still have one going to this day 13 years later. My Intel hardware in general has been as bulletproof as hardware gets. I actually believe Intel is underrated and underappreciated. Their quality assurance while not perfect, is the best. My current system is 100% Intel and Samsung.