5 ms·
> have been fine Citation needed, there's a lot of disagreements and misunderstandings (some have cost lives) that could've been avoided if we didn't have 10 d
by moffkalast 4y ago
> have been fine
Citation needed, there's a lot of disagreements and misunderstandings (some have cost lives) that could've been avoided if we didn't have 10 different ways to say the same vague thing that can be interpreted in 20 ways. You think the military uses a phonetic alphabet and specifically structured communications for fun? Or the way planes talk to ATC for example. Where precision and unambiguity is crucial, natural language always gets ditched for something more formal.
- groestl 4y agoThanks for that. A lot of energy is currently sunk because of natural language, and I'd argue gains from employing software (instead of human processes) for various tasks is in part due to scaling up the results of many confusing discussions in natural language about what a specific process actually comprises.
- b112 4y agoThis is part of the reason Google search sucks more and more. Around when Android appeared, and the first voice searches began, Google suddenly started to alias everything. Search for 'Andy', 'Andrew' appears. Search for 'there', and 'they're' appears. This has been taken further, now silly aliases such as debian .. ubuntu exist, and as google happily drops words in your search, to find a match, this makes precision impossible. But, that's the only way to make voice search remotely work, so...
- jefftk 4y agoI don't think this is to support voice search: Google generally knows whether a query was initiated by voice or typing. Instead, I think it's because most users find what they're looking for faster with it. If you have terms you don't want interpreted broadly you can put them in quotes.
- bluGill 4y agoMost people are not precise enough in their terminology.
- Zach_the_Lizard 4y agoGoogle "helpfully" ignores the quotes sometimes too. They're not the hard and fast rule they used to be. I preached the Gospel of Google when the competition was composed of web rings and Altavista, but Google in its infinite wisdom has abandoned the advanced user with changes of this nature.
- thfuran 4y agoSo what is the gospel de jour, or are we forsaken in these benighted times?
- jvolkman 4y agoPretty sure quote support has improved recently. https://blog.google/products/search/how-were-improving-search-results-when-you-use-quotes/ https://blog.google/products/search/how-were-improving-searc...
- b112 4y agoConsidering the article lies, and tries to claim quotes always are respected, I wouldn't put much faith in it.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoI find voice-assistant often useful for using the phone such as opening a given setting, say make the display brighter. Trying to navigate the settings pages is very error-prone. There seems to be no universal standard as to where each setting should be found.
- b112 4y agoThe real problem is people keep reorganizing where the settings are found.
- numpad0 4y agoThere is a widely accepted and straightforward thinking that humans has ideas, which are expressed in languages, and that languages being ambiguous is problematic: this I'm starting to have doubts on. Maybe we don't have clear intentions in the first place, maybe languages are not just ambiguous, but only meant to narrow realms of valid interpretations down to a desired precision, rather than intended to form a logically fully constrained statements. Maybe this is why intelligent entities are needed to "correctly" interpret natural language statements, because an act of interpretation itself is a decision making and an action. Just my thoughts but I do think there are more to be said than "natural languages are ambiguous".
- _jpys 4y agoThis is actually an interesting point. In the Army, we used terms that limited ambiguity thereby increasing efficiency. Even if one eliminates the complexity of language, there's still a specification problem. I only use voice assistants to set alarms. I cannot imagine voice as a primary input. Then again, many have opted out of owning desktops and laptops in favor of mobile phones. That also seems terribly inefficient.
- ghaff 4y ago>Then again, many have opted out of owning desktops and laptops in favor of mobile phones. That also seems terribly inefficient A lot of people don't need computers in the general purpose sense. I admit my mind boggles a bit when co-workers tell me their kids don't want a computer to do their school papers because their phone is fine. But, then, I'm used to keyboards and what we think of as a "computer" and have been using one for decades--and grab one when I can for any remotely complex or input-heavy task.
- moffkalast 4y agoIt sounds ridiculous, but I'll admit that when you've got something like Dex that lets you dock the phone for usb and hdmi out and gives you close to a full desktop OS I'd imagine it really is enough for the casual user.
- ghaff 4y agoI certainly know colleagues in the industry who travel with just a tablet and external keyboard. No, they're not running IDEs etc., but they find it OK for emails, editing docs, taking notes, etc. Personally I'll spend the extra few pounds to also carry along a laptop. But I can imagine not needing/wanting a dedicated laptop when I travel at some point.
- iso1631 4y agoIs a tablet and keyboard really much lighter than a laptop? https://www.theverge.com/2020/4/20/21227741/apple-ipad-pro-magic-keyboard-weight https://www.theverge.com/2020/4/20/21227741/apple-ipad-pro-m... Suggests a keyboard and large tablet is heavier than a laptop