3 ms·
Voice assistants are shit. The number of times my friends have got alexa to turn the light on first time is functionally zero. And, they don't really explain t
by ggm 4y ago
Voice assistants are shit. The number of times my friends have got alexa to turn the light on first time is functionally zero.
And, they don't really explain the syntax constraints. Which are massive.
Try ab initio without knowing how to do it, to get OK google to open an arbitrary google authored app and direct it to do something. Compared to learning how to use the OS UI keyboard shortcuts or applescript. (Which btw like Windows is basically fully documented because all the libraries are self documenting for their call structures)
The voice interfaces are universally badly designed because spoken command sentences are not well understood as a modality of command, distinct from mouse, gesture, touch or keyboard.
Until voice is baked in with a documented syntax in "man" format, i won't believe its first class.
How do I even know for any arbitrary app what voice directives it uses? How do they correlate to any other command input? How consistent is this with other commands in other apps? Does "stop now" always mean the same thing between a mapping routing app, and a tape backup app? Isn't "stop" contextually defined in a way ^C isn't?
- dmitriid 4y ago> The number of times my friends have got alexa to turn the light on first time is functionally zero. I have a room called "Study" and the only lights there are called "Main Lights". - Hey, Siri, study lights 100% - Did you mean these lights: "Study: Main Lights" :facepalm:
- ggm 4y agoYea, a single member set shouldn't require full enumeration, it's detectably the only operating device in context. If it was the only "main light" across all rooms I'd hesitate to say the same mind you, nesting scopes should be respected. What would you want it to do when you add a second light bulb? Tell you the old command is no longer unique or turn on both?
- dmitriid 4y ago> What would you want it to do when you add a second light bulb? Tell you the old command is no longer unique or turn on both? I think when the command is generic "lights" it should turn on all lights. But both are valid behaviours.
- r0m4n0 4y agoI don’t disagree with the stupidity sometimes but I have probably upwards of 50 lightsbulbs/plugs connected to my echo speakers and use them exclusively for turning on my lamps, dimming lights etc. so I can say confidently, it makes mistakes sometimes but once you learn the quirks and set things up with proper names it’s actually pretty impressive. And you can learn the oddities, you just have to be dedicated, sorta like learning anything else. I’ve learned that I can’t say “what’s the temperature” because it will tell me the temperature my Dyson fan is set to lol. It’s not wrong, it’s just missing some context (me holding my jacket wondering if I should wear it) that I can provide going forward. Maybe I should just ask it “should I wear my jacket today”
- dmitriid 4y agoThat's the issue though: there are too many quirks even for the most simple of interactions.You have to be constantly aware of quirks, and issues, and workarounds. It's like walking on broken glass.
- spookthesunset 4y ago> set things up with proper names The hard part isn't naming the stuff, its remembering what each thing is named. I could call the lamp next to the couch several different things depending on the context. If you don't remember exactly what it is named you are gonna have a rough time. I've been tempted to just put a label with the device name on everything controlled by Alexa. And good luck getting a guest to turn anything on or off.
- dmitriid 4y ago> I could call the lamp next to the couch several different things depending on the context. Or just call it dude :) https://reddit.com/r/tumblr/comments/548b3p/everything_is_dude/ https://reddit.com/r/tumblr/comments/548b3p/everything_is_du...
- eternityforest 4y agoI bet you could sell a lot of fully offline voice assistants that just did timers and maybe reminders that sync to the phone or other smart speakers with bluetooth. No privacy concern if there's no WiFi at all! I'll stick to Google assistant for the extra occasionally useful stuff, but the idea of a device that won't stop working if the server goes away is pretty cool.
- zamalek 4y ago> The number of times my friends have got alexa to turn the light on first time is functionally zero. Do your friends have accents? Alexa frequently fucks up due to my South African/Zimbabwean accent. I joke that Alexa is racist. Google seems to handle it way better. Here's hoping that Mycroft does better (which I plan to switch to in the coming months).