3 ms·
A publisher per se may be not needed. Upload some PDF. But a curator and a reviewer are pretty important roles. One for selecting and surfacing the important a
by nine_k 4y ago
A publisher per se may be not needed. Upload some PDF.
But a curator and a reviewer are pretty important roles. One for selecting and surfacing the important and high-quality, the other fir checking soundness and weeding out poorly done stuff.
Those are the actual paid services of, say, Elsevier. The rest us cruft and rent-seeking.
Now the question: how well are these services rendered by the publishers? Can this be done more efficiently, with higher quality? If so, how? Are there examples?
- signaru 4y agoOne problem is poorly done reviews. Especially since many reviewers are not being paid anything for their time and have the incentive to ward off competing researchers while being protected by anonymity. It seems hopeless since who else would the publisher go to to assess the quality of supposedly new pursuits of expertise knowledge? I've had experienced many strawman rejections back in the day that I just stopped trusting the publishing system. I'd rather just upload a PDF and let the readers judge its credibility and let (positive) citations be the benchmark instead on trusting a handful of elite critics with unclear incentives.
- UncleMeat 4y agoAnd, as you say, the expensive publishing houses don't do anything to ensure high quality reviews. In grad school I had a paper rejected by a prestigious outlet because one reviewer thought that the experimental setup I used was too difficult and therefore they didn't trust that I was being honest about my results. They stopped just a step short of calling me a fraud. I was baffled that this was accepted by the publisher. It was only later when I was tasked with performing reviews that I realized that almost exactly zero work is done by the publishers. It is just "well there's one Strong Reject so see-ya."
- Certhas 4y agoThose services are provided by editors and reviewers to Elsevier for free. Reviewers and Editors are _not_ paid by the publishers. That is why there was hope for flipping journals. The experience of Gowers and co with Discrete Analysis shows that high quality selective journals outside of publishers are straightforward, and that we are overpaying publishers by a factor of ~100. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discrete_Analysis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discrete_Analysis