4 ms·
And if they tax it, people will complain about cost-shifting, saying the consumer should pay, and accuse the taxes for driving inflation etc. I am in favor of m
by anigbrowl 4y ago
And if they tax it, people will complain about cost-shifting, saying the consumer should pay, and accuse the taxes for driving inflation etc. I am in favor of making polluters account for negative externalities, it's been a long-theme of my comments here), but I've noticed that people are adept at inventing new bases of objection.
Perhaps you could suggest a place where the pollution taxation approach has worked and the enforcement has teeth, which you would be happy to see implemented here even though it might come with short-term costs.
- WalterBright 4y agoCost incentives work. It's why people buy cars that get more mpg. Why wouldn't they prefer to buy a car that engenders a lower pollution tax?
- rgmerk 4y agoIf by “people” you mean “Americans”, they buy F-150s to go to the grocery store, and they vote out governments that threaten their ability to do so. Taxing pollution, particularly consumer-facing taxes, has a long history of political failure, whereas subsidising clean technology has a long history of political and technical success.
- waldothedog 4y ago*F-250
- rjbwork 4y agoSaw an F-450 the other day... granted, it was at the gun range, but I was there in my compact hatchback and it had not a spec of dust on it.
- maeil 4y agoIt doesn't simply "have a long history of political failure"; it has a history of political failure in certain areas of the United States. In much of the rest of the developed world, e.g. nearly all of Western-Europe, it has a history of success and taxing cars based on fuel consumption and emissions has indeed caused buyers to gravitate towards more fuel-efficient cars.
- WalterBright 4y agoDo they tax the rate of emissions, or the amount emitted? It's important to tax the latter.
- maeil 4y agoBoth. The former directly through taxes on the cars themselves and the latter indirectly through fuel taxes, which while imperfect works well as a proxy.
- WalterBright 4y agoFuel taxes work well for CO2 emissions, but not for other emissions, where the design of the ICE can reduce them dramatically.
- rgmerk 4y agoFair point, but the EU ETS took many, many years to have any serious effect as I understand it.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf we can have a sales tax, we can have pollution taxes.
- rgmerk 4y agoIn the United States, you can't, at least at a federal level, nor across most of the red states.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI was hoping for examples of incentives for this specific problem you considered successful and would express support for if implemented here.
- refurb 4y agoAnd if they tax it, people will complain about cost-shifting, saying the consumer should pay The consumer should pay, because that will reduce demand. It’s funny to see a government encourage a carbon tax to reduce fossil fuel use (high gas prices drive consumers to look for alternatives), then turn around this year and either cut gas tax or send out checks to consumers to offset higher gas prices. Not sure any politician has the Will to follow through with it.