2 ms·
In the 50s, my dad was stationed in Europe and was watching Italian TV. The press tracked down the guy who won the lottery, and cornered him at the entrance to
by WalterBright 4y ago
In the 50s, my dad was stationed in Europe and was watching Italian TV. The press tracked down the guy who won the lottery, and cornered him at the entrance to his apartment building. The press asked him "now that you won the lottery, what are you going to do with the money?"
Another man pushed him aside, and answered "oh, he's a Communist Party member in good standing, he's going to give it all to the Party!"
The lottery winner shot back "Oh no, I'm not a Communist anymore!"
My dad always had a belly laugh when he recounted that story.
- bumby 4y agoWe can both agree and laugh at the hypocrisy of people, but I don’t think that undermines the point the way you think it does.
- WalterBright 4y agoOr maybe the problem is you view it as hypocrisy. I don't. It's illustrative of perfectly normal and predictable human behavior. The surprise would be if he did give it all to the Party. My dad wasn't laughing at him. He was laughing at the Communists with their inability to recognize their false god.
- bumby 4y agoPerhaps I misunderstood. My take-away was that, if he truly believed in Communist principles, he would give his money away. The fact that he didn't, shows his party affiliation wasn't a principled stance. I can acknowledge there are other more pragmatic motivators for being a Communist/Ba'athist/[insert political party of choice here]. I'm certainly not making a case for Communism. Again, it's telling that that is the lens you view these discussion through.
- WalterBright 4y agoMy lens is pretty transparent(!). I've baldly stated it several times. I make no secret of my world view.
- bumby 4y agoThis is true. My point is not everything should be shoehorned into that dynamic. It’s not unlike when someone twists any misgiving into evidence of their pet cause, whether it’s racism, statism, misogyny, etc. The existence of those doesn’t mean every bad thing in society should be attributed to them.