This was actually my next suggestion when Obsidian got shot down. It's definitely a nice half way house between the two. Again it got dismissed albeit this time

This was actually my next suggestion when Obsidian got shot down. It's definitely a nice half way house between the two. Again it got dismissed albeit this time with no explanation, I assume because the request for feedback and suggestions wasn't actually anything of the sort but basically a pretend exercise on behalf of management to 'show we're listening'.