4 ms·
There's still an important distinction between "the semantic web" and "a bunch of cryptocurrency fuckery", both of which have been termed "Web 3" at times.
by ceejayoz 4y ago
There's still an important distinction between "the semantic web" and "a bunch of cryptocurrency fuckery", both of which have been termed "Web 3" at times.
- k__ 4y agoThe distinction is that "the semantic web" went nowhere and "a bunch of crypto currency fuckery" has millions of users globally.
- ceejayoz 4y agoI'm with you on the success (or lack thereof) of the semantic web. I don't consider gambling a good thing just because there are millions of gamblers. I feel the same about cryptocurrency.
- k__ 4y agoHow is using a decentralised Twitter alternative like Lens gambling? How is using a decentralised Zoom alternative like Huddle01 gambling? How is using a decentralised Pusher alternative like Push gambling? I agree, that in the last years most web3 apps focused on financial/blockchain specific use-cases. I also agree, that many of them had quite dubious claims. But that's not all there is and I think, that won't be the reason it will gain mainstream adoption.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWhich of those have the "millions of users" the upthread comment referred to?
- k__ 4y agoGood point. The ones I wrote probably just have a few 10k max. Maybe, the Internet Archive is a better example millions of users?
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe Internet Archive is a web3 project? It was founded in 1996. Web 2.0 didn't exist then.
- k__ 4y agoObviously it didn't start as one, but projects can transition, right? Seemingly, the Internet Archive and Protocol Labs are bros. https://blog.archive.org/2021/04/01/filecoin-foundation-grants-50000-fil-to-the-internet-archive/ https://blog.archive.org/2021/04/01/filecoin-foundation-gran...
- kabdib 4y agos/user/sucker/g
- nailer 4y agoWeb3 isn't about cryptocurrency, it's about owning your own identity instead of Google, Apple, Facebook.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWhat "web3" project doesn't involve a cryptocurrency concept as a technological underpinning?
- nailer 4y agoWith a zero balance, identity. Identity is simply connecting to a wallet and reading a signed DID - the wallet could have zero balance and it still works. Boom you just signed into something without Google / Facebook / Apple. With close to a zero balance (but not quite zero) to pay transaction fees, you can do peer to peer encrypted messaging without central arbiters. With close to a zero balance (but not quite zero) to pay transaction fees, you can send vast quantities of stablecoins to the otherside of the world - that said a web3 skeptic may consider stablecoins to be a cryptocurrency (there's arguments either way, they're tokens but not minted via proof of stake) and capitalisation is an issue. Edit: reply to peoplefromibiza, who made some good points, due to rate limit: > wallets are a cryptocurrency concept yes, agreed. But they do a lot more than let you speculate on cryptocurrencies. Right now I'm working on wallet for people who have zero interest in speculating on cryptocurrencies. > you can do the same thing with a client certificate yes agreed. You can think of web3 as a better PKI. I do.
- peoplefromibiza 4y agowallets are a crtptocurrency concept. you can do the same thing with a client certificate, boom, you are who the cert says you are.
- larsonnn 4y agoThis.
- 4y ago