3 ms·
From what I’ve seen, the main complaint from board game enthusiasts about Risk is that the dice rolling is too random (I don’t really agree with this, the whole
by bee_rider 4y ago
From what I’ve seen, the main complaint from board game enthusiasts about Risk is that the dice rolling is too random (I don’t really agree with this, the whole point of the game is to control your level of risk, there it is right in the name, so if your plan hinges on good rolls it is just a bad plan. But I digress).
I think most people who are really into board games must have a general ability to separate in game behavior from normal behavior.
Actually I think there is a different phenomenon with Risk, for many years it was one of the few board games with any aspect of strategy or conflict that would be played by people who weren’t totally into board games (I mean excluding the super serious games like Chess and friends). So there are some people out there who aren’t really into boardgames generally (some of whom don’t have the requisite ability to detach their ego from a game), but are “into” Risk specifically and can get uncomfortably intense about it.
Catan is pretty good IMO. There’s a general disagreement I think between rules-purists and people who want to play fast-and-loose with the rules. The problem is that technically you always have to exchange cards to trade — so, technically it is allowable to extort people with your soldiers and the robber, but you have to at least set up a sham trade for it which adds some annoying friction; it is more fun if you say “giving cards away for free is fine” and allow an economy of extortion to flourish. And anyway if somebody doesn’t say “I’ll give you a sheep if you go get me a beer” is it really Catan? If you played it with some rules sticklers, give it another try IMO.
- ghaff 4y agoRisk was a preferred game both while I was in school and for some time afterwards in our ski house, etc. It definitely appealed to people who weren't broadly into board games--and certainly not hardcore war games. I always liked it. There are some potentially annoying dynamics like how cards dominate so much in the end game and basically force you to go for it at some point. I've played Catan on a tablet. It's OK but I seem to keep coming back most to Carcassonne for that general class of game.
- yamtaddle 4y agoRisk's much improved by goal-oriented or score-based gameplay variants, which tend to feature as the standard ruleset in newer versions and derivatives (Risk 2210, SPQRisiko, et c) for good reason. Conquer-the-world takes too long for a game that tends to eliminate half its players early on.