5 ms·
Qatar World Cup critics are unprepared for the rest of this century
- AftHurrahWinch 4y agoNo paywall: https://archive.ph/KhMHW https://archive.ph/KhMHW "Vietnam, that 100mn-strong beneficiary of friend-shoring, is “not free”, in US watchdog Freedom House’s reckoning. Indonesia, the fourth most populous nation on Earth, is just “partly free”. So too is much of the subcontinent, from where lots of the mistreated workers in Qatar have come. There is no western counterbalancing of China, no Asia strategy at all, without the help of some or all of these nations. ...the outrage over Qatar — whose host status we have had 12 years to get used to — has been stunning. I am glad it exists. Give me Enlightenment chauvinism over the pretence that all models of government are equal... The outrage reveals something about those who feel it, though. It is plain now that lots of people have paid lip service to the idea of a changing world, a less western-skewed balance of power, without reckoning with its practical effects... ...Four months have passed since Joe Biden bumped fists with Saudi Arabia’s crown prince... ...He knows that victory depends on enlisting allies that fall short of the Jeffersonian ideal of governance. Others are slower to the same realisation. Liberals have traded relativism for a universal conscience just as the world makes such a thing unaffordable."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- skinnymuch 4y agoVietnam not free according to some US watchdogs? How surprising.
- jacooper 4y agoProviding one of the best infrastructure and preparations the World cup has ever seen, spending 220 billion dollars to do it, and introducing the world cup to a region that has been severely neglected historically, are all amazing achievements by Qatar. And doing all that while showing your traditions and identity is even better. Western governments claim to be the champions of Human rights, while Invading Iraq, Afghanistan and supporting the Apartheid occupation in Palestine. The human right problems in Qatar are peanuts compared to what the West (governments) did in the Middle East. Yet we don't go on a moaning spree every time the US hosts an event, or every time western politics get injected into sports. It's our time to host sport events we have always dreamed of, and it's our time to show our culture like you always did.
- whateveracct 4y agoYou could protest anything about the USA in the USA without being arrested or incarcerated. If foreigners protest next WC, they will not be arrested. And there will not be a threat of arrest chilling their speech. There are actual differences here. Is restricted speech part of the "culture"? What about illegal homosexuality?
- jacooper 4y agoI agree, Freedom of speech needs to improve. Of course part of the problem is western governments supporting military coups. > Is restricted speech part of the "culture"? I mean I can't go joking around as a Nazi in Germany, yet that's not banned in the US. > What about illegal homosexuality? That is part of the culture. We and many others don't accept it, simple.
- mola 4y agoIllegal homosexuality was part of western culture. Which we know meant untold numbers of hurt individuals. PPL would get beaten up, blackmailed turtured and generally had crappy life because of that "culture". We can't force "our" new culture on anyone, but we certainly don't need to pretetnd that we accept theirs. If you call apartheid to what's happening in Israel, than what do you call the treatment if minorities in all other Arab countries? Because in Israel non jews are in parliament, executive branch (ministers), in the judicial system (judges) in academia , Are graduating as doctors and lawyers , are journalists etc. If that's apartheid, than how on earth can you say that making homosexuality illegal is just a matter of culture? Being gay is a much more basic defining property than a nationality. And Israel doesn't even make calling yourself a Palestinian or raising the Palestinian flag illegal. You are delusional.
- benj111 4y agoI don't think politicians should be so pure that they don't deal with anyone that don't live up to their ideals. I also think we should be able to criticise other cultures without being accused of racism, or requiring our own countries to be perfect. Ultimately we live on a small planet. We need to get along with our neighbours, even if we don't agree with some things they do. I don't think that's hypocracy.
- 543g43g43 4y agoI hate football, but have been very excited for this World Cup for a while. It has not disappointed. Only a handful of games have been played, and major world groups have truly been brought together. Ancient, intolerant cultures, hypocritical "woke" money- and power- grabbers, and a sport-loving populace who openly do not care about either set of issues. People love to talk about the paradox of "tolerating intolerance", but it is a very self-correcting issue. If you tolerate intolerance for long enough, you will find yourself in an intolerant society.
- dirtyid 4y agoBasic some-what educated napkin math: Qatar: ~650 deaths per year from ~2M low end migrant labours doing construction under harsh conditions. USA: ~900 deaths per year from ~1.5M "temporary workers" AKA migrant labours in various sectors doing similarly intensive labour under harsh conditions (i.e. agriculture farm hands). I'm guessing Qatar critics not interested in crunching those ratios and portion rage accordingly. Keep in mind Qatar is country with 3M people where ~10% or 300K are citizens, then some professional expats, then a fuckload of migrant workers. Relative amount of remittances flowing out of Qatar to disproportionately improve lives in Asia / Africa is huge. Workers are still get paid multiple for what they would back home relative to skill set. Contiions in Qatar = hazard pay. Granted it's out of Qatars hands to demographically not rely on outside labour, but IMO their per capita remittances are easily net good. Yeah they could treat workers better and mitigate (which they have over the years like other Gulf states), but I'm betting if you ask countries that supply Qatari labour if they'd fine with 10x more deaths for 10x the remittance boosting development, they'd pick more deaths in a heart beat. For each labour that dies or gets fucked by VISA scams, multiple more are using remittances to generations of family members out of poverty.