3 ms·
It would be a slightly darker earth. The net warming from CO2 addition is a few watts/m^2. Insolation is something shy of two orders of magnitude higher. Dim
by pfdietz 4y ago
It would be a slightly darker earth. The net warming from CO2 addition is a few watts/m^2. Insolation is something shy of two orders of magnitude higher. Dimming sunlight by a few percent is not a large change.
- SomeBoolshit 4y agoI'm gonna wait until we're sure about the effect on every living organism on earth.
- pfdietz 4y agoBecause that same standard is being applied to CO2 emission, right? What a double standard you have.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoWhy would you consider a few percent of sunlight change to be meaningless whereas a few degrees (a smaller percent, temp should be considered in Kelvin) is extremely meaningful?
- pfdietz 4y agoWhy should I not? I'm at a loss to understand why you think you're making a good argument there. There are far larger changes in insolation over the day and over seasons. Life is obviously less sensitive to these flucuations, than life would be to changes in temperature.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoEach argument is symmetrical! There are large fluctuations in temperature over space and time as well! Presuming that one matters and one doesn’t is making an assumption that needs to be proven at minimum, whereas the null hypothesis should be something like “it is not clear what changing the baseline temperature or light levels of an environment will do, but it’s probably bad for the ecosystem”.
- pfdietz 4y agoThe size of the fluctuation in insolation is very much larger than the change in temperature. One goes from 1000 W/m^2 in noon sun to, what, milliwatts/m^2 from starlight? Many orders of magnitude. Temperature goes from maybe 250K to 320K over the year, maybe, a change of maybe 30%?