7 ms·
Lost 8th century Japanese medical text by Buddhist monk has been found
- boxmonster 4y ago
- dang 4y agoWe've banned this account for posting unsubstantive and flamebait comments. Abusing HN like this will get your main account banned as well, so please don't. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- krunck 4y ago"Lost 8th-century Japanese medical text by Buddhist monk has been found in a book published in 2009."
- miniwark 4y agoYep it's weird. From the title only, it look like Liu et al. made a discovery, when the main protagonist is in fact Lei Yutian, the descendant of one of the disciples. Thanks must be made to his masters for preserving this recipes during 52 generations.
- nl 4y agoIt's a pretty amazing story, and shows that if you do something (like publish a book) but can't get it in front of the right people then you might as well not have done it. > The first person to teach traditional Chinese medicine in Japan was an 8th-century Buddhist monk named Jianzhen (Ganjin in Japanese), who collected some 1,200 prescriptions in a book: Jianshangren (Holy Priest Jianzhen)'s Secret Prescription. The text was believed lost for centuries, but the authors of a recent paper published in the journal Compounds stumbled across a book published in 2009 that includes most of Jianzhen's original prescriptions. > That's how they stumbled upon a 2009 book entitled Three Treasures Be Published. It turns out that before he left for Japan, Jianzhen gave a copy of his many prescriptions to one of his disciples, a monk named Lingyou. The text passed through 52 subsequent generations, until Lingyou's descendent, Lei Yutian, decided to organize all the prescriptions into his 2009 book. 52 generations passed down through one family is quite incredible. I'm not aware of anything else like that that has ended up published, although I could be uninformed.
- pseingatl 4y ago"52 generations passed down through one family is quite incredible." I think that's the real story here.
- googlryas 4y ago52 generations of teachers passing it to their disciples, not 52 generations of the same family. Much easier to do since someone's son might be a little shit with no recourse but you probably aren't going to train a disciple for years and then have them turn out to be untrustworthy. This is more like a copy of some important christian manuscript getting passed down from St Peter to Pope Francis 260 times over the past 2000 years.
- shakna 4y ago> This is more like a copy of some important christian manuscript getting passed down from St Peter to Pope Francis 260 times over the past 2000 years. That's actually still pretty incredible. There's a reason that large document caches are our main source for the translations of the Bible, today. Preserving even religious documents through all the upheavals of time and politics, is not a small matter, even if they have a large team dedicated to it. (Which early on, was not the case).
- nl 4y agoI read it as 52 generations of the same family. It's one of the decendants who published it.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>can't get it in front of the right people then you might as well not have done it. "If a tree falls in a forest but nobody is there to witness, does it make a sound?"?
- rippercushions 4y agoYou can only wonder how many documents like this were lost in China during the Cultural Revolution, when thousands of temples and everything else associated with the Four Olds [1] were willfully destroyed. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Olds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Olds
- wil421 4y agoReminds me of a Tibetan library I saw on Reddit the other day. Here’s the wiki link[1]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sakya_Monastery https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sakya_Monastery
- abudabi123 4y agoDam construction in Egypt and China very likely destroyed documents waiting to be found.
- WaitWhatHuh 4y agoAnyone know where we can read/study these ancient medicines? The article talks about it - but completely just leaves that bit out. Kind of a tease?!
- shakna 4y agoThe 2009 book in question is "Three Treasures" [0] [0] https://www.amazon.com.au/Three-Treasures-Exploration-Focusing-Huangdi/dp/1702014037 https://www.amazon.com.au/Three-Treasures-Exploration-Focusi...
- chips_n_fries 4y agoI collect old medical textbooks and I strongly believe our doctors today know less than did doctors at ~1900. Would be amazing to know what information even older medical texts contained.
- Herodotus38 4y agoI agree they probably knew more medical information, but how much of it was correct… There’s the famous cliche of the medical students first lecture. (Paraphrasing) The professor goes up and says “Fifty percent of what you learn here will be found to be wrong in 20 years. The problem is we don’t know which 50%. Read about the history of cancer research and its various themes as to the origin of cancer as a great look into just one subset of medicine. EDIT: Another great way to see the errors of the past is to read wikipedia articles on American presidents and read how they died. Their final diagnoses and treatments are often vague and shocking (respectively) and often people are wondering if they would have survived if they hadn't been attended to by physicians of the time, which were probably the most well-renowned. For example, Zachary Taylor or George Washington.
- bearmode 4y agoI absolutely guarantee you that they don't.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoI see a lot of people romanticizing the turn of the century 20th century. “Money was harder then” or “people had more grip strength”. This is a first time I have heard someone claim (Western) doctors were more advanced.
- partomniscient 4y agoTalk about cognitive dissonance. If they're going to use those colours on a map the land should be the greenish colour and the sea the blueish one.
- teddyh 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue%E2%80%93green_distinction_in_language#East_Asian_languages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue%E2%80%93green_distinction...
- groffee 4y ago> Lost 8th century Japanese medical text by Buddhist monk has been found ..by checking the local bookstore. Seriously, modern 'researchers' need to just take their blinkers off and especially go cross-discipline.
- vharuck 4y agoWhy call it a "Japanese medical text" if it was written by a Chinese monk and left with one of his disciples in China before leaving for Japan?
- thatguy0900 4y agoThey are also claiming it as a discovery by the scholar when he found it in a book published in 2009, seems very biased overall