3 ms·
That's the lovely thing about the oh-so-fungible thing called "money", and white-collar crime. The stolen car is a recognizable and emotive thing, with an iden
by bell-cot 4y ago
That's the lovely thing about the oh-so-fungible thing called "money", and white-collar crime. The stolen car is a recognizable and emotive thing, with an identity all its own.
Vs. the vague and amorphous "money", which so easily flows from being bits in a computer here, to marks on a sheet of paper there, to bits in some other computer... The emotions of the neutral human observer don't stick to it nearly so tightly. And a huge number of politicians, business exec's, lawyers, and other "friends" of white collar crime are naturally quite resistant to the "you should give it back" notions of the little people...
- pja 4y agoThis isn’t always the case. People who took cash out of Madoff’s ponzi scheme had to return it & take their proportionatey share of the total returned to all investors in exchange. Cash that’s been paid out from a bankrupt company can be clawed back by the bankrupty trustee. Usually this only applies to payments made shortly before the company goes under though.
- bell-cot 4y ago> This isn’t always the case. People who took cash out of Madoff’s ponzi scheme had to return it & [...] Quite true. And I've not followed the details about SBF's schemes...but it sounds like he's different from Madoff in three important respects, all of which seem likely to make claw-backs less viable: - Diverting funds to cover trading losses at an allied & now-bankrupt firm. If Madoff had (say) directly lost $1B by buying some stock which then fell in value, would there have been any possible claw-back on that $1B? I'd bet "no". - Lots of funds were "laundered" through various sorts of crypto transactions. Anything "crypto" is probably a far greasier pig, to try to wrestle the real money back. - Layers of corporate structure, HQ'ed in an offshore tax haven. IANAL, and certainly not a lawyer qualified in tax haven corporate securities law, but this sounds more like a gold mine for the lawyers than good news for the victims.