3 ms·
I can’t say I followed all of that and I felt pretty tired by the end of everything/ one tagged with some level of privilege, sexuality… something. It’s one o
by duxup 4y ago
I can’t say I followed all of that and I felt pretty tired by the end of everything/ one tagged with some level of privilege, sexuality… something. It’s one of my pet peeves to see everything labeled like that. I think it is unfair to everyone labeled/ distilled.
That aside…
I did find this aspect something appealing.
> such questioning should take place in an atmosphere of comradeship and solidarity, and probably not in public in the first instance
Someone involved in the education system in my area recently said something unwise.
They apologized, explained themselves in detail.
A few weeks later they finally resigned after a lot of pressure.
The response to the resignation by the folks opposed to this person was “Well he is not alone, I bet the other people on that board feel the same way.”
I couldn’t help but wonder then, wouldn’t it be better to have someone who sincerely apologized and discussed their words openly on that board?
If the whole shaming/ calling out can only end in some level of ostracizing, won’t people just be better about hiding those things? Does that do us any good?
I have trouble with all the shaming / calling out if there isn’t an endpoint/ no chance for anyone to be better.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Someone involved in the education system in my area recently said something unwise. > They apologized, explained themselves in detail. > A few weeks later they finally resigned after a lot of pressure. TLDR: If you're ever the target of a mob, your chances are innumerably better by simply refusing to resign. A non-zero chance of keeping your job (by not resigning) is infinitely better than the 0% chance of keeping your job (by resigning). --------------- In all the high-profile cases of people targeted by cancel-mobs, apologising only increases the pressure the target experiences. Apologising is taken as an acceptance of liability and admission of guilt to much more than what was originally accused. If the target apologises, and then resigns, then they lost their job due to their own actions and no individual in the mob can be pointed out as the person perpetuating cancel-culture, and the mob feels vindicated: After all, they wouldn't have resigned if they didn't say/do anything wrong, would they? If the target resolutely ignores the mob, and refuses to resign, then someone has to fire them, and that someone has to at least pretend to have investigated, and that someone could still be on the hook if the mob was wrong anyway.