2 ms·
Heck, even much of the press in the US is confused about it. It is quite common for cert. denied to be reported as the Court affirming the lower court's decisio
by tzs 4y ago
Heck, even much of the press in the US is confused about it. It is quite common for cert. denied to be reported as the Court affirming the lower court's decision that is being appealed.
All cert. denied means is that the Court decided not to hear the case. That may be because they agree with the lower court, but that is just one reason they might decide not to hear the case.
Another reason they might decide cert. is that although they think the case raises issues that they need to deal with, the particular circumstances of this particular case don't present the issue as clearly as they would like. They want to wait until a better case comes along with the issue.
Sometimes they want to wait until appeals courts in different regions have considered the issue and explored different approaches to it so more of the possible arguments on both sides have been hashed out.