4 ms·
https://stackoverflow.com/a/6957469 https://stackoverflow.com/a/6957469 This seems very elegant and clean and I don’t know the slightest bit of Haskell other t
by Waterluvian 4y ago
https://stackoverflow.com/a/6957469 https://stackoverflow.com/a/6957469
This seems very elegant and clean and I don’t know the slightest bit of Haskell other than “MONADS!!!”
- thedataangel 4y agoThe one you linked is close to how you'd write this in idiomatic Haskell. The paper is describing a particular technique, and using FizzBuzz as an example problem, not suggesting that the technique is a good way to solve FizzBuzz.
- throwaway81523 4y agoI don't like that solution very much because of the 4 cases, or generally n*2 cases if there are n tokens. My favorite Haskell solution uses monoids (specificaly the Monoid instance of Maybe String) and is quite natural in Haskell but would take some explanation for non-Haskellers. My version looks like the below. I didn't originate the approach but I like this spelling. It won't make total sense to non-Haskellers though. {-# LANGUAGE MonadComprehensions #-} import Data.Maybe import Data.Monoid fizz :: Int -> String fizz n = fromMaybe (show n) $ f 3 "Fizz" <> f 5 "Buzz" where f :: Int -> String -> Maybe String f d msg = [msg | n`rem`d == 0] main = mapM_ putStrLn [fizz n | n <- [1..100]] This extends in an obvious way to FizzBuzzHissHowl, lets the Monoid instance manage concatenating the special tokens together while remembering if any of the rules have matched, and uses a monad comprehension on the Maybe monad to cleanly lift the token into the Maybe monad if the number is a multiple of whatever. The type annotation on f is added to make it a little bit clearer what is going on. The use of monoids and the monad comprehension may be slightly flashy, but the use of Maybe to remember whether a rule has triggered is second nature in Haskell.
- turboponyy 4y agoThis is not too dissimilar to the final solution outlined in the essay, but is much more readable, in my opinion, due to its use of mappend over Maybe Strings instead of implementing the same sort of compositionality using regular function composition. Very elegant!