4 ms·
Is there anything which involves both... (1) lots of subtle and subjective judgement calls (2) humans yearning to show off their wealth / sophistication / sta
by bell-cot 4y ago
Is there anything which involves both...
(1) lots of subtle and subjective judgement calls
(2) humans yearning to show off their wealth / sophistication / status
...which is NOT fake or widely-faked?
- JasonFruit 4y agoI can totally tell the difference in sound between a long-pattern Strad and a golden-period one, so you just back off, champ.
- TremendousJudge 4y agoText editor choice. Those are definitely, completely, for sure real.
- bombcar 4y agoThere are zero subjective calls there, however. My choices are objectively correct and laid down by God Himself, all others are ontologically evil.
- voxelghost 4y ago>My choices are objectively correct and laid down by God Himself, all others are ontologically evil. Hello fellow spaces over tabs person
- iso1631 4y agospaces at the start of the line, tabs between function arguments
- Tepix 4y agoIf i use Visual Studio but with vim keybindings, am i faking it? ;-)
- tptacek 4y agoI don't know about judging the binary, but there are more- and less- faked luxury good appreciations. Whiskey is less faked than wine is (but, like most things, the distinctions blur as you go up in price; that makes, like, a kind of basic economic sense, right?)
- TheDong 4y agoYou can "no true scottsman" your way to make that true or false, depending. I might say "Cars and yachts are not so widely faked, but are both status symbols", but then you might say "ah, but those are less subjective. A yacht objectively does not sink, and a car objectively needs less maintenance or goes faster or has better ride quality" I might say "having a subjectively defined set of books on your bookshelf is a sign of sophistication and status, and is not widely faked", but you might say "ah, but the books are objective, having 1984 and K&R C are objectively a sign of programmer status" I might say "owning a 'nice house' in a big city is a status symbol, 'nice' is very subjective, but it's not widely faked", to which you will point out reality is fake and I cannot even prove houses are real in the first place.
- aziz77 4y agofollow up thoughts assuming that _everything_ lives on a simple spectrum of least faked and most faked (1) I posit that certain demographics are _aware_ of the 'fake's or 'widely-faked' things(material, immaterial, symbolic) which they willingly or unconsciously/historically/inadvertently subscribed/habituated/endowed into (1a) how do we ascertain where ourselves (and others) are on that scale of awareness (1b) of the groups who belong on the _less aware_ side of the awareness spectrum, what are the classes of fake things which they subscribe to that they will not concede to be fake at all (2a) Is there a demographic that willingly/consciously/unconsciously wants to be deceived (2b) What are the classes of things which they normally want to be deceived by? Connection between wine connoisseurs and notion of high-status is generally accepted and the connection between status, self esteem and serotonin is well established [1-3]. There is one interesting study (which unfortunately i cant access) on rationality (or rather suppression of) during blind wine testing [4] which i presume iterates this point in context of wine Solomon et al expounded Terror Management Theory[5] based on Becker's Denial of Death[6] which suggests one experimental measure for ascertaining degree of irrational attachment (or degree of irrationality); given a threat or reminder of death, humans will strongly assert whatever symbolic attachment (eg religion, race, choice of text editor, wine vs non wine loving, wine choice, truffle choice) they have and discriminate anyone who belongs to the 'other' due to the serotonin triggering nature of asserting the value of your attachment/identity. What i do want to see is a social/fMRI study of technological workers and 'fashion' ie irrational/subjective choices made in supposedly rational/objective domains (choice of text editors etc), related [7] [1] Sylwester, Robert. "Serotonin, students, and self-esteem." The Education Digest 63.2 (1997): 16. [2] Breuning, Loretta Graziano. Habits of a happy brain: retrain your brain to boost your serotonin, dopamine, oxytocin, & endorphin levels. Simon and Schuster, 2015. [3] Pyszczynski, Tom, et al. "Why do people need self-esteem? A theoretical and empirical review." Psychological bulletin 130.3 (2004): 435. [4] Caltagirone, C., et al. "Rational versus emotional behavioral responses in wine tasting: a transcranial magnetic stimulation experiment." American association of wine economists annual conference. 2011. [5] Greenberg, Jeff, Tom Pyszczynski, and Sheldon Solomon. "The causes and consequences of a need for self-esteem: A terror management theory." Public self and private self. Springer, New York, NY, 1986. 189-212. [6] Becker, Ernest. The denial of death. Simon and Schuster, 1997. [7] Breuning, Loretta. "The neurochemistry of science bias." Groupthink in Science. Springer, Cham, 2020. 3-14.